From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-02 23:56 · #73798 in PRATCHETT
Hi Quentin, [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] QS> Absolutely disagree: Fair enough.... QS> if you want to tarnish anything with that, then the culprit must be 2001 .. but *why*? There's no point in putting something like this if you're not going to back it up with reasons. Why do you consider that 2001 did harm to the SF genre? GM> Think about some of the films... GM> Close Encounters: "Just because you feel like a misfit doesn't GM> mean that you can't be special" feel good plot. QS> Please elaborate. The hero, Roy Neary, is a bit of a wimp, doesn't relate to his family, is a basic nobody, but he manages to succeed in getting on the alien ship. GM> Terminator 2: a chase movie with a time travel sub plot and tons GM> of pretty effects. QS> BTW I note that you don't mention T1, which somewhat destroys your QS> argument. Ok, Terminator was cheap (about 6 million IIRC), but I did say "practically every"... Also T1 didn't exactly bother with much of a plot (it was a padded out short story) and, again, the characters didn't have much depth. GM> There are plenty more where these came from, but they have all relied on GM> flashy special effects and huge sets to try to conceal the fact that the GM> characters are two dimensional and the plots are simple. QS> While many films, fit your bill, there are many that don't. I'd also QS> point out that these are 15 years and more after Star Wars. So which films do you think don't? I think that The Black Hole and Jurassic Park fit in perfectly! QS> Films like The Black Hole are good counter-examples (Maximillian being a QS> very believable 'different' villain), with Jurassic Park being the QS> ultimate counter-example. Eh? Maximillian wasn't anything special AIR, he was basically an archetypal mad scientist. As for the film itself, it was standard Disney fodder, not exactly one that stands out! And Jurassic Park?? What was that if not a big budget FX fest? QS> But the key has nothing to do with the FX or any other individual QS> aspect: it is the suspension of disbelief. Suspension of disbelief is all very well, but after watching half a dozen or more "action" movies with lots of FX and no plots or characters, don't you feel the need for something with a little more depth and bite to it? Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)