From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-03 01:03 · #73799 in PRATCHETT
Hi Mark, GM> Ok, time to stir up a little controversy and get people talking...! MS> Oh dear, cue another Marsden & Stevens debate! Hopefully (well, actually) not just you and me. I also hope that people will start disagreeing with each other's points in this thread so it expands and kicks off new topics, instead of me having to handle it all. [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] MS> I'd say it's the exact opposite, Ok (at least you've backed this up with reasons...) GM> ever since Star Wars came out, practically every SF film has been a big GM> budget special effects fest with lots of big sets, but with minimal GM> attention being paid to either plots or characterisations. MS> I think the problem here is defining exactly what a sci-fi film is. Didn't we do this thread a few weeks back?? ;-) MS> A film can contain elements of sci-fi without being explicitly sci-fi. MS> Ie, 'Forever Young', 'Jurassic Park', 'Tank Girl' Yes, I accept this, however I'm not going to get into the "is it SF or not" argument again at the moment! MS> and the forthcoming 'Powder' and 'Twister'. Which jogs my memory about something I was meaning to talk to you about. You mentioned in your "Moderator's Manifesto" about posting the latest news etc. I think this might be a good idea after all and I don't think anyone would mind seeing a few pieces of news every week, as long as they are of reasonable interest (eg new productions, latest releases) etc. What sort of news info do you get and how much is there of it? (Reply by netmail if it would be too big to post in here.) MS> The main problem could be to do with audience expectations. Audience expectations, or the film studios' opinions of what the public want to see? MS> For a long time, the very best sci-fi has always been found in literary MS> format. It wasn't until the likes of '2001' and 'Blade Runner' that the MS> sci-fi film found a proper cinematic foothold. But that's only two films out of *how many*? Why can't we have more 2001's and Blade Runner's? What is it about these films that makes it so difficult to produce others with plots and characters? (Or is it just that special effects are easier and less taxing on the mind?) GM> Think about some of the films... MS> (I'll quote the lot for completeness) And I'll cut it...! ;-) MS> The thing is, you can break down any plot of any film into such MS> simplistic terms. Yes, of course, but it's a matter of whether there is anything else left once the plot has been broken down to its elements. Are there sub-plots which make you think? Do the characters have depths such that they actually *exist* outside the film? If the answer is no, then this is the sort of thing that I am objecting to. MS> This phenomenon isn't exclusive to the sci-fi genre. You cited 'Alien', MS> but isn't it just a jazzed up monster hunt? Yes, but there is more to it than that. Ok, most of the characters are pretty shallow eg Lambert, Parker and Kane (a hell of a waste of John Hurt's acting talents) but Ripley, Ash and Dallas make up for this. You also have the whole background of "the Corporation" which considers its employees to be expendable assets and its methods of forcing them to do its bidding and, finally, the question (although it was never really addressed in the first film) of where the Alien came from. All of these combine to make it a much better film than the standard fare. MS> Even the theme of 'Blade Runner' (can the human experience be replicated MS> and still remain just as unique?) has been addressed before (see the TOS MS> episode 'What Are Little Girls Made Of?'). Umm, how about "Frankenstein"? (Possibly a slightly better example!) MS> And '2001' asks the age-old question, "Who's the more fallible -- man or MS> machine?". Hmm, I didn't see 2001 in that way. IMO Kubrik and Clarke were taking the mickey out of Humanity's ego trips of "hey, we've put a man into space" etc and saying "so what? There's a whole big universe out there, you aren't anything special". MS> I'm not dismissing those film, but you can't really convince me that the MS> likes of 'Star Wars' or 'ET' are in any way invalidated as strong movies MS> just because [of simple plots] You can break down *any* film in a MS> similar fashion. But, as I said above, if that is *all* there is to the story and the characters then, IMO, they *are* invalidated. GM> they have all relied on flashy special effects and huge sets to try GM> to conceal the fact that the characters are two dimensional and the GM> plots are simple. MS> Within a 2 hour framework, there's only so much you can do. Really? So how come the films that *do* manage it do it? MS> you haven't contrasted it with examples of what you believe to be MS> well-rounded characters and well-structured plots. Give me the name of a MS> decent pre-'Star Wars' sci-fi movie and I'll name you a decent MS> post-'Star Wars' one. Ok, try The Day the Earth Stood Still, Forbidden Planet, This Island Earth, 2001, Phase IV and The Andromeda Strain. GM> It is my contention that Hollywood has been so seduced by the "look GM> what we can do with the lights" mentality that they have failed to GM> apply the basic rules of what makes a good film to the SF genre MS> I can't quite see where your arugment is coming from. You're MS> saying that 'Star Wars' has destroyed the sci-fi film? Hardly. MS> There were good and bad sci-fi films before 'Star Wars' and there MS> have been good and bad sci-fi films since 'Star Wars'. Yes, I haven't said there weren't. My contention is, however, that it has become too easy to put in flashy special effects where the character and plot development ought to be. Star Wars was such a quantum leap in FX that everyone in Hollywood was totally dazzled by it and immediately jumped on the band wagon saying "gosh, we've *got* to have lots of special effects in our next film too" in an attempt to cash in on Star Wars' success, forgetting to include such trivia as characterisations or plotting. MS> What are the "basic rules" of a good sci-fi film then? At the end MS> of the day, a good film is a good film regardless of genre. The "basic rules of a good sci-fi film" are the same as the basic rules of *any* good film. Unfortunately they have been applied to SF films very infrequently and, IMO, even less frequently after Star Wars. GM> IMO the SF film is a dying breed but that no one has yet noticed GM> because they are so dazzled by the pretty pictures that they can't see GM> that it is all superficiality and no depth. MS> Define "decent sci-fi film". Done elsewhere in here... MS> you mentioned 'Blade Runner' and 'Alien', but the case you've presented MS> against the likes of 'Star Wars' applies equally to them. Covered elsewhere... MS> I suspect you're only trying to be controversial in order the get a MS> juicy thread going and don't really have the full courage of your MS> convictions, but I'd love for you to prove otherwise. Ah. Oops! Ok, guv, it's a fair cop! ;-) Seriously, though, yes, perhaps the initial posting was deliberately intended to be controversial by attacking Star Wars, however I feel that the general principle of SF films being a victim of their own FX (hey, that's a pretty neat pun!! ;-) ), still holds true. GM> There have been a *few* good films, but they cannot make up for the GM> dross which is churned out in the name of science fiction. MS> In recent memory, what about 'Strange Days' or 'The City of Lost MS> Children'? Then we've also got 'Twelve Monkeys' to look forward to MS> within the next month. Err, which ones? I haven't even *heard* of these! (See comments above about news etc). Ok, I haven't watched been watching eg Film '96 as often as I used to, but these are totally unknown to me. GM> So, what do you think? MS> Well, your argument that there are only a few good sci-fi films amongst MS> plenty of dross applies to every other genre under the sun. True. MS> I can't quite see what you're trying to say, because all you've done is MS> go, "This is the way it is and we should blame 'Star Wars'." Star Wars was picked as the first major example of the modern style of special effects (as opposed to wobbly flying saucers and rubber aliens). However, as someone else mentioned, ever since T2 practically every SF film has had morphing, mainly, IMO, because it is cheap and looks good. I think that because George Lucas managed to produce these effects in such a quantity and manner he totally derailed any other form of SF development as everyone got stuck on the "flashy effects" track. Parallel examples might be the "space race" where it has been claimed that if Kennedy hadn't wasted all that money on going to the moon we could have had the shuttle ten years before we did and much cheaper or the Crusades where if the barbarian europeans hadn't beaten the hell out of the more socially and scientifically developed eastern countries we wouldn't have had the dark ages and civilisation and technology could have been a couple of hundred years more advanced by now. I'm not saying that we *wouldn't* have the same sort of films we do now if Lucas hadn't made Star Wars, but I don't think he actually helped the situation that much. MS> All we can really do is blame crap film-makers and support the good ones Yes, but (another parallel), if 20 million people watch Eastenders who is going to bother making quality drama? MS> There's good stuff out there -- just go and look for it. I'm looking...! Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)