Slimelite BBS

Good books

Back to PRATCHETT

From Robert Bull · 1996-04-04 03:00 · #73797 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Good books by Eoghann Irving

Hello, Eoghann;

31 Mar 96 14:39, Eoghann Irving wrote to Robert Bull:

 RB>> Crawford Killian "Eyas"  (a truly extraordinary novel that reads

 EI>      Crawford Killian.  I had a long conversation with him on usenet a
 EI> couple of years ago.  He used to post to one of the writing
 EI> newsgroups.  I always meant to look up some of his books.  I take it
 EI> you think he's a good writer.  You don't know of any others he's
 EI> written do you?

"Eyas" is marvellous, genuinely unique; certainly I've never read anything 
remotely similar.  People get married in fours, the ghosts of the dead are 
ever-present spiritual cannibals, centaurs are allies, the creatures that 
stalk the landscape include the terrible Walkingtree but are less baleful 
than the warlike religion of the Suns, and yet it turns into SF in the end 
not quite fantasy.  Strange and wonderful.

If you have access to CompuServe you might try the American Books in Print 
that (I think) they have for a list, though Killian may be out of print 
now.  He has written at least one other book though I don't know its title; 
I saw it in a shop, read the cover blurb, and decided that Killian's agent 
must have persuaded him to write something straightforward, all-American 
and commercial.  Since I haven't read it, I may be wrong!  He hasn't got a 
very high profile, anyway.

 RB>>>> a fantasy called "Tigana" by  Guy Gavriel Kay, the source of a

 EI>      Another Tigana fan.  Great.  Its one of my favourites.  Have you
 EI> read A Song For Arbonne?  Its almost as good I think.  Nothing works

Not yet - not supposed to be quite as good as "Tigana" but still better 
than most of the field.

 EI> out quite the way you expect it too.  I can't get over how much better
 EI> Guy's writing has got since The Fionavar(sp?) Tapestry.  That was an
 EI> okay trilogy, but nothing spectacular.  Has he written anything else?

I've got but not yet read the first of the Fionavar Tapestry (yes, there 
_is_ and "a" between the "n" and the v"!).  The latest Kay is  called "The 
Lions of Al Rassan," or something close to that.  I can only quote from a 
review; the flavour is of mediaeval Spain with neo-Jew/Christian/Muslim 
religions, but the critic wondered why Kay had bothered with the fantasy 
setting and low-key magic, why not just set in in historical Spain.

     Regards,

              Robert.

--- GoldED 2.50+
 * Origin: Pointing at Minerva * 28 lines/12Gigs * 0181-402-3350 (2:254/33.4)