Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF

Back to PRATCHETT

From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-07 08:50 · #73947 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF by Graham Marsden

Tuesday April 02 1996 17:56, Graham Marsden wrote to Quentin Stephens:

 GM>> There are plenty more where these came from, but they have all
 GM>> relied on flashy special effects and huge sets to try to conceal
 GM>> the fact that the characters are two dimensional and the plots are
 GM>> simple.

 GM> I think that The Black Hole and Jurassic Park fit in perfectly!

That's being a bit unfair on 'Jurassic Park'. It was never meant to be hard sci-fi, nor was it meant to be a cerebral film. What it *is* is a very well crafted action movie that knocks you for six on the big screen. If your jaw didn't drop during the T-Rex sequence and you didn't turn to your partner/mates afterwards, breathlessly going, "Wibble!" then you really should start learning how to enjoy cinema more!

I saw JP in Milton Keynes and when the T-Rex sequence finished, you could feel the entire cinema buzzing with excitement. Everyone was fanning themselves (it was a hot day too) and giving it, "Wurble!" The theatre's ventiliation system was also turned up a notch as a cold wave of fresh air blew over everyone. Great cinema and Spielberg's an expert at this sort of thing. The only thing that's come close since is the Harrier sequence in 'True Lies' -- truly stunning.

(You watch, I'll now get Johnny 'Just Watches Videos' Smith replying to me, going, "But I saw True Lies on video and it wasn't that spectacular." Like, duh - get a clue. Films are for the cinema, not a poxy TV set.)

 QS>> Films like The Black Hole are good counter-examples (Maximillian
 QS>> being a very believable 'different' villain), with Jurassic Park
 QS>> being the ultimate counter-example.

 GM> Eh? Maximillian wasn't anything special AIR, he was basically an
 GM> archetypal mad scientist.

Maximillian was the big black robot, not the scientist. The scientist was played by Maximilliam Schell though (if I remember correctly). And 'The Black Hole' is enormous fun - don't knock it! :)

 GM> As for the film itself, it was standard Disney fodder, not exactly
 GM> one that stands out!

But when you're 7 years old (as I was when I first saw it at the cinema), it's excellent! Whenever I watch it these days, I can still recall the sense of wonder that surrounded it during its original release. If I saw it for the first time tomorrow, I'd agree that it's a complete load of old crock.

 GM> And Jurassic Park?? What was that if not a big budget FX fest?

Who's saying it was meant to be anything else? It was designed to get people to sit in a cinema for 2 hours and go, "Cor!" and that's precisely what happened. 

 QS>> But the key has nothing to do with the FX or any other individual
 QS>> aspect: it is the suspension of disbelief.

 GM> Suspension of disbelief is all very well, but after watching half a
 GM> dozen or more "action" movies with lots of FX and no plots or
 GM> characters, don't you feel the need for something with a little more
 GM> depth and bite to it?

But we do get that. I don't know about you, but I'm a big cinema buff and see as much as possible. I get my fair share of quality movies, so if something like 'Jurassic Park' comes along and entertains me with mind-blowing CGI, I'm not gonna go, "Bah, all fx and no plots or characters."

If you're only going to the cinema infrequently and limiting yourself to certain types of films, then no wonder everything's going to look like a big non-event. I mean, you've said yourself, "Where are all the decent sci-fi films?", I mention 'Strange Days' and you go, "Eh? What's that?" Make more of an effort and stop moaning! :)


 .+'''+.    fido  ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27
 M A R K    email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk
 `+.,.+'    www   ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/

--- GEcho 1.00
 * Origin: Playing in the Snake Park (2:254/151.27)