Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF

Back to PRATCHETT

From Quentin Stephens · 1996-04-07 16:56 · #73906 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF by Graham Marsden

On 02-04-1996, Graham Marsden said 

GM> [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than
GM> good]
GM> 
GM> QS> Absolutely disagree:
GM> 
GM> Fair enough....
GM> 
GM> QS> if you want to tarnish anything with that, then the culprit must be 2001
GM> 
GM> .. but *why*? There's no point in putting something like this if
GM> you're not going to back it up with reasons.

I saw no point in reposting your reasons.

GM> Why do you consider that 2001 did harm to the SF genre?

I don't believe it did. It's just that it was the first.
 
GM> GM> Think about some of the films...
GM> 
GM> GM> Close Encounters: "Just because you feel like a misfit doesn't
GM> GM> mean that you can't be special" feel good plot.
GM> 
GM> QS> Please elaborate.
GM> 
GM> The hero, Roy Neary, is a bit of a wimp, doesn't relate to his
GM> family, is a basic nobody, but he manages to succeed in getting on
GM> the alien ship.

He was invited AFAIR.
 
GM> GM> Terminator 2: a chase movie with a time travel sub plot and tons
GM> GM> of pretty effects.
GM> 
GM> QS> BTW I note that you don't mention T1, which somewhat destroys your
GM> QS> argument.
GM> 
GM> Ok, Terminator was cheap (about 6 million IIRC), but I did say
GM> "practically every"... 

The holes appear. :}

GM> Also T1 didn't exactly bother with much of a
GM> plot (it was a padded out short story) and, again, the characters
GM> didn't have much depth.

I think that they had more than was necessary. Part of the plot was
the robot's gaining of character.

GM> GM> There are plenty more where these came from, but they have all relied on
GM> GM> flashy special effects and huge sets to try to conceal the fact that the
GM> GM> characters are two dimensional and the plots are simple.
GM> 
GM> QS> While many films, fit your bill, there are many that don't. I'd also
GM> QS> point out that these are 15 years and more after Star Wars.
GM> 
GM> So which films do you think don't?

Wargames for one. As for others, I have to confess that my mind's gone
blank, so I'll have to cede for the moment.

GM> I think that The Black Hole and
GM> Jurassic Park fit in perfectly!
GM> 
GM> QS> Films like The Black Hole are good counter-examples (Maximillian being a
GM> QS> very believable 'different' villain), with Jurassic Park being the
GM> QS> ultimate counter-example.
GM> 
GM> Eh? Maximillian wasn't anything special AIR, he was basically an
GM> archetypal mad scientist.

Max was one of the robots, not the scientist.

GM> As for the film itself, it was standard
GM> Disney fodder, not exactly one that stands out!
GM> 
GM> And Jurassic Park?? What was that if not a big budget FX fest?

Jaws on land. Mnd you, the scene where the chief warden gets it did
remind me of Tarzan and the rubber lion.
 
GM> QS> But the key has nothing to do with the FX or any other individual
GM> QS> aspect: it is the suspension of disbelief.
GM> 
GM> Suspension of disbelief is all very well, but after watching half
GM> a dozen or more "action" movies with lots of FX and no plots or
GM> characters, don't you feel the need for something with a little more
GM> depth and bite to it?

I don't watch too many action movies (no TV). But yes, I do enjoy
things like Pride and Prejudice - and was very annoyed at having missed
it at the local cinema.

QTS

Home: qts@donor2.demon.co.uk, qts@nildram.co.uk \\|//
0[888888]----------------------------------------[:]--
Work: qts@buckscc.gov.uk                        //|\\
Disclaimer: I do not speak for BCC
Posted on Sunday 07-04-1996
--- Maximus/2 3.01
 * Origin: DoNoR/2,Woking UK (44-1483-725167) (2:440/4)