Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-07 03:10 · #73943 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Graham Marsden

Tuesday April 02 1996 19:03, Graham Marsden wrote to Mark Stevens:

[Blame Star Wars!]

 MS>> A film can contain elements of sci-fi without being explicitly
 MS>> sci-fi. Ie, 'Forever Young', 'Jurassic Park', 'Tank Girl'

 GM> Yes, I accept this, however I'm not going to get into the "is it SF or
 GM> not" argument again at the moment!

I like to reaffirm these sort of things, because even though I've mentioned such things millions of times before, you'll always get someone going, "Yeah Mark, but you've got remember that... <repeats what I said weeks ago>".

 MS>> 'Powder' and 'Twister'.

 GM> What sort of news info do you get and how much is there of it? (Reply
 GM> by netmail if it would be too big to post in here.)

Well, I could post as much or as little as possible. I didn't know what everyone's general level of awareness was as far as sci-fi productions are concerned. If no-one's heard about 'Powder' and 'Twister' then they're a bit behind the times!

Very briefly... 'Powder' is about a strange young man, the colour of chalk powder, who harbours some very strange powers. Set in contemporary USA. Don't know that much more about it, except that it didn't really please the critics.
Watch out for 'Twister' though -- it'll be one of the big summer movies. Steven Spielberg produces Michael Crichton's first screenplay written directly for film (as opposed to being based on a novel). It's directed by Jan de Bont (Speed) and stars Bill Paxton (Apollo 13, Aliens), Helen Hunt and Cary Elwes. It's about two scientists sent to Arizona to investigate an abnormal amount of tornado activity. The trailer's just started appearing in US cinemas and the tornado effects are meant to be spectacular.

Back to the Star Wars debate...

 MS>> The main problem could be to do with audience expectations.

 GM> Audience expectations, or the film studios' opinions of what the
 GM> public want to see?

I won't go into mega detail in this post because I've since made various comments in other posts. It's a double-edged sword though -- audiences and the studios can both share the blame. I mean, take something like 'Strange Days'. The best sci-fi film we've had since 'The Abyss' and no-one's going to see it. It's been advertised everywhere but for some reason the audiences aren't going, yet they're packing out the likes of 'Johnny Mnemonic', which was perhaps less advertised. So what does the film studio do? Do they keep making 'Strange Days' type movies that no-one will see, or do they continue dishing out a load of old cobblers in the form of 'Johnny Mnemonic'. If the general public are only interested in the latter, then you can't blame the production studios for not taking risks.

 MS>> For a long time, the very best sci-fi has always been found in
 MS>> literary format. It wasn't until the likes of '2001' and 'Blade
 MS>> Runner' that the sci-fi film found a proper cinematic foothold.

 GM> But that's only two films out of *how many*? Why can't we have more
 GM> 2001's and Blade Runner's?

In the sci-fi genre, there are perhaps fewers classics than you'd find in other genres. In a post I made yesterday, I mentioned that you usually only find one or two real 'classic' sci-fi movies in a decade, whereas in the gangster genre alone, the 1990s have already given us 'Goodfellas', 'Reservoir Dogs', 'Carlito's Way', 'Pulp Fiction', 'The Usual Suspects' and 'Casino' -- each one a true classic takes the genre just that little bit further.

So, why the lack of classics? Well, the sci-fi genre is still considered a bit of a 'fringe' job. Okay, you and and I know that it shouldn't be, but the general movie-going public tend to be a bit evasive when it comes to sci-fi movies. Of course, they'll go and see the likes of 'Jurassic Park' or 'T2' without thinking twice, but then there's a lot of cross-over involved there. As I explained above, the more cerebral sci-fi movies (Blade Runner for instance) don't tend to fare all that well at the box-offices. It's well known that BR originally bombed at the box-office and it's only recently become a cult success. So, if the production companies don't see anyone coming to see their extravagant, cerebral sci-fi movies, then why should they risk raking out the readies for further non-events?

Of course, it's wrong -- companies *should* take more risks and show the general public that these sorts of films are worth seeing. And it's films like 'Star Wars' that *do* convince the Doubting Thomases out there. You watch, when the new SW movie is released within the next few years, we'll see a glut of sci-fi movies that will pull in the crowds. The production companies will then have a second chance to keep the audiences there, and with any luck they will. It worked in the case of 'Blade Runner'. If it wasn't for 'Star Wars', it probably wouldn't have been made.

[Simplifying movie plots]

 MS>> The thing is, you can break down any plot of any film into such
 MS>> simplistic terms.

 GM> Yes, of course, but it's a matter of whether there is anything else
 GM> left once the plot has been broken down to its elements. Are there
 GM> sub-plots which make you think? Do the characters have depths such
 GM> that they actually *exist* outside the film? If the answer is no, then
 GM> this is the sort of thing that I am objecting to.

But 'Star Wars' was never intended to be a cerebral sci-fi movie. It was intended to pay homage to the serialised matinee shorts that packed huge audiences into cinemas of a Saturday morning. It was always intended to be a roller-coaster swashbuckler and the sci-fi trappings are just incidental. It's the same thing with 'Raiders of the Lost Ark'.

You can't deny that 'Star Wars' is an incredible cinematic experience. What George Lucas managed to do was create something that was as big a crowd-puller as the cheap & cheerful matinees, but with the epic feel of a David Lean movie. In doing so, he created the phenomenon of the summer blockbuster -- check your movie history and you'll find there was no such concept before 'Star Wars'. 'Star Wars' was designed to amaze people and put the thrill back into the cinema, and that he did.* Can you name a sci-fi film predating 'Star Wars' that was a box office blitz, critically acclaimed and technically light years ahead of anything else? Nah! You can't! ;)

    * 'Jaws' also went some way to achieving something similar, albeit on a
      smaller scale.

[Alien]

 MS>> Isn't it just a jazzed up monster hunt?

 GM> Yes, but there is more to it than that.

[...]

 GM> You also have the whole background of "the Corporation" which
 GM> considers its employees to be expendable assets and its methods of
 GM> forcing them to do its bidding and, finally, the question (although it
 GM> was never really addressed in the first film) of where the Alien came
 GM> from.

An unresolved plot-thread! How did you cope? ;)

 GM> All of these combine to make it a much better film than the standard
 GM> fare.

Yes, but these extra trappings aren't exactly exclusive sci-fi film devices. What you're essentially saying is that 'Alien' was a more densely textured movie than we normally get.

 MS>> And '2001' asks the age-old question, "Who's the more fallible --
 MS>> man or machine?".

 GM> Hmm, I didn't see 2001 in that way.

Perhaps more prevalent in '2010', but it's still there.

 MS>> You can't really convince me that the likes of 'Star Wars' or 'ET'
 MS>> are in any way invalidated as strong movies just because [of simple
 MS>> plots] You can break down *any* film in a similar fashion.

 GM> But, as I said above, if that is *all* there is to the story and the
 GM> characters then, IMO, they *are* invalidated.

So you're saying that 'Star Wars' and 'ET' aren't good movies? I think they're both brilliant. Perhaps you should stop thinking of them as sci-fi movies. If a movie has sci-fi trappings, then it should be assumed that it's trying to compete with 'Blade Runner' or '2001'. It's unfair to say that 'ET's a bif naff because it's not as good as '2001'. They're entirely different movies, aimed at different audiences. At the end of the day, they both entertain their target audiences. '2001' is the thinking (wo)man's sci-fi film, whereas 'ET' is a kid's movie. I could just as well say that '2001' is a naff kid's movie, but that will get us nowhere. As it happens, 'ET' is a *wonderful* kid's movie and Spielberg has a nack of relaying that child-like wonder to an adult audience. Very few directors can do that.

 MS>> Give me the name of a decent pre-'Star Wars' sci-fi movie and I'll
 MS>> name you a decent post-'Star Wars' one.

 GM> Ok, try The Day the Earth Stood Still, Forbidden Planet, This Island
 GM> Earth, 2001, Phase IV and The Andromeda Strain.

Le Dernier Combat, The Terminator, Robocop, The Abyss, Children of the Lost City and Strange Days. Could have mentioned Alien and Blade Runner too.

 GM> My contention is, however, that it has become too easy to put in
 GM> flashy special effects where the character and plot development ought
 GM> to be.

Same with other movies though, not just sci-fi.

 GM> Star Wars was such a quantum leap in FX that everyone in Hollywood
 GM> was totally dazzled by it and immediately jumped on the band wagon
 GM> saying "gosh, we've *got* to have lots of special effects in our next
 GM> film too" in an attempt to cash in on Star Wars' success, forgetting
 GM> to include such trivia as characterisations or plotting.

But sfx is just another tool in the film-maker's armoury. The lack of decent special effects in films before 'Star Wars' didn't stop people from making naff scripts. Of course, it's still a valid excuse but you can really say it's George Lucas's fault that other production companies tried to emulate what he'd done and failed. Blame the people who made the crap films, not the person who made the decent one.

 GM> The "basic rules of a good sci-fi film" are the same as the basic
 GM> rules of *any* good film. Unfortunately they have been applied to SF
 GM> films very infrequently and, IMO, even less frequently after Star
 GM> Wars.

I disagree -- there were just as many naff sci-fi films before 'Star Wars'. What you've got to consider is whether we'd have had 'Blade Runner' had 'Star Wars' not existed.

 GM> Seriously, though, yes, perhaps the initial posting was deliberately
 GM> intended to be controversial by attacking Star Wars, however I feel
 GM> that the general principle of SF films being a victim of their own FX
 GM> (hey, that's a pretty neat pun!! ;-) ), still holds true.

Yes, it does hold true, but I don't think there's any 'post Star Wars' or 'pre Star Wars' argument here. 'Star Wars' showed just what film technology could do and allowed people to consider sfx for their own movies. But it doesn't mean that this option has created a problem. The problem has always been there, but now there are just more fingers to point at if things go wrong. There'll always be good movies and there'll always be naff movies and the ratio won't change that much. But the best ones will still continue getting better and I reckon there'll be a fair few sci-fi ones amongst them.

 MS>> In recent memory, what about 'Strange Days' or 'The City of Lost
 MS>> Children'? Then we've also got 'Twelve Monkeys' to look forward to
 MS>> within the next month.

 GM> Err, which ones? I haven't even *heard* of these!

Blimey! A sci-fi fan who *hasn't* heard of at least *one* of these? Graham! Shame on you. Briefly... 'Strange Days', written by James Cameron and directed by Kathryn Bigelow (responsible for the excellent 'Point Break'). It's New Year's Eve 1999 and the Squid phenomenon has gripped San Francisco. Real-life experiences can be recorded and are then sold back on the black market to customers seeking various (and usually illegal) thrills. Ralph Fiennes is a cop who gets involved in the black market and soon finds himself in deep poo-poo when he discovers some Black Squids he perhaps shouldn't have. 'Strange Days' is the best SF movie we've had for ages -- great script, gorgeous visuals and some amazing stunts. A proper cyberpunk movie -- none of this 'Johnny Mnemonic' business. May still be around a local cinema if you're lucky.

'The City of Lost Children'... French sci-fi from Jean-Pierre Jeunet and Marc Caro, responsible for the whacky 'Delicatessen'. A renegade clone and his brothers are tapping into dreams of lost children, supplied to them by a being known as the Octopus. A retired flea-circus owner and a cult of cyborgs investigate... Quite surreal, but visually stunning. I think it's available to rent on video. Was in the cinemas around September last year.

'Twelve Monkeys' -- look out for this, it's in the cinemas any time now. Directed by Terry Gilliam, starring Brad Pitt & Brice Willis. Bruce is from the future, where a lethal virus is wiping out mankind. He travels back in time to try and prevent it but is commited to an asylum. He shares this asylum with Brad Pitt, who although a complete nutter, seems to hold the key to mankind's possible survival, and it's all got something to do with the mysterious Army of the Twelve Monkeys... Went down a storm in the US and will probably do so here. Word is, if you like 'Brazil' then you'll love this.

With films like that I can't see how you can claim there's no decent sci-fi around -- you're just not watching it!

Back to SW's 'negative' influence...

 GM> Star Wars was picked as the first major example of the modern style
 GM> of special effects (as opposed to wobbly flying saucers and rubber
 GM> aliens).

 GM> However, as someone else mentioned, ever since T2 practically every SF
 GM> film has had morphing, mainly, IMO, because it is cheap and looks
 GM> good.

I can think of plenty of SF movies since T2 without morphing. Trouble is, those who loved the morphing in T2 seemed to go out of their way to catch it everywhere else. Remember the discussions in here following 'Star Gate's release? Everyone was going, "Whoar! Morphing!" It's not really *that* widely-used -- I just think there's more people in this echo who make a point of seeing the movies that *do* have morphing and not seeing the ones that don't.

 GM> I think that because George Lucas managed to produce these effects in
 GM> such a quantity and manner he totally derailed any other form of SF
 GM> development as everyone got stuck on the "flashy effects" track.

Completely untrue.

 GM> Parallel examples might be the "space race" where it has been claimed
 GM> that if Kennedy hadn't wasted all that money on going to the moon we
 GM> could have had the shuttle ten years before we did...

That's just idle speculation. Besides, the space race was never about getting into space, it was proving to the other side just what your technology could do. Look what happened when the USSR crumbled, the space race completely subsided. Of course, it's back on track now as they've finally decided it might actually be worth venturing beyond our planet. The US/Russian space-station will commence building in December 1997 and should be almost complete in 2001 (if current shuttle schedules stay on course).

Besides, if you ask me, if 'Star Wars' was never released, we wouldn't have had 'Blade Runner' and would currently have *less* sci-fi movies.

 GM> I'm not saying that we *wouldn't* have the same sort of films we do
 GM> now if Lucas hadn't made Star Wars, but I don't think he actually
 GM> helped the situation that much.

Why on earth are you blaming George Lucas? He made a bloody excellent movie (well, three excellent movies if you include 'THX-1138' and 'American Graffiti') If you want someone to blame for [poo] sci-fi movies, then blame the ones making them! Are you going to blame Asimov and Clarke for the overwhelming cascade of naff sci-fi novels we've got at the moment?

 GM> Yes, but (another parallel), if 20 million people watch Eastenders who
 GM> is going to bother making quality drama?

Good quality drama is being made. What about 'This Life', 'Our Friends in the North', 'Ghostbusters of East Finchley', 'Roughnecks', 'Pride & Prejudice', 'Martin Chuzzlewit', 'Hamish Macbeth', 'Ballykissangel' etc etc?

 MS>> There's good stuff out there -- just go and look for it.

 GM> I'm looking...!

Obviously not hard enough!


 .+'''+.    fido  ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27
 M A R K    email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk
 `+.,.+'    www   ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/

--- GEcho 1.00
 * Origin: Virtual Hmmm... (2:254/151.27)