Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-03 01:57 · #73800 in PRATCHETT

Hi David,

[Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good]

 GM> ever since Star Wars came out, practically every SF film has been a big
 GM> budget special effects fest with minimal attention being paid to either
 GM> plots or characterisations.

DO>  I'm now inclined to go with Tony Pressley who I read as saying
DO> that film is essentially a superficial medium.

But is it? Ok, yes, you can put more detail into books because they don't
have to run for about 90 - 120 minutes, but surely there have been plenty of
films which have managed to include depth.

 DO> We get runs of films...
 GM> this has been going on for twenty years.

DO> Probably because the FX have still been developing. There will come a
DO> point when we are on a new plateau where every film has perfect FX
DO> and film-makers will start looking around for other hooks to get
DO> the public in the door.

Well then, let's hope that that time comes soon and the hooks they use are
character and plot development!

 DO> There was a relative glut of SF films in the seventies...
 GM> Care to mention any names?

DO> They show up all the time on TV - The Andromeda Strain springs to mind,

An example I've used myself a few times in this thread already!

DO> one with the base being attacked by yellow ants,

Phase IV, another good one.

DO> The Philidelphia Experiment (iffy),

*Well* iffy!!

DO> Silent Running, that kind of thing. Anything with long spaces where
DO> nobody is talking.

I'm really not sure about Silent Running. Yes, it is an intelligent and
thought provoking film, but, IMO it just drags on too long.

 DO> SW was the first of the all-action extravaganzas, but I don't think
 DO that George Lucas is somehow "to blame";

 GM> Ok, I have to admit that that comment was deliberately inflammatory,

DO> I haven't got an axe to grind WRT George Lucas... I've never been
DO> a major SW fan.

Fair enough. I did, however, pick Star Wars because it was the first example
of this sort of film and represented a quantum leap in the way that SF films
were (and are) made and presented.

DO> ironic that the trashcan robot was the most well-drawn character ;)

*Beep* bloop bloop *wheeoooo*!

 GM> I think it might have been more a case of "wow! Look! We can put in
 GM> lots of special effects and people will be so dazzled by them that they
 GM> won't notice how naff the film is!"

DO> Doubt it - the FX are integral, not dropped in afterwards. Everybody
DO> starts with just a script, and that has to read well.

Hmm, call me a cynic, but I think it goes "look at all the fancy special
effects we can do. Let's get someone to write a story so we can use them!"

 DO> trend at the moment is towards remakes of old TV series.
 GM> Oh *whoopee* clucking doo!!! :-(

DO>  I'm curious to see the Dr Who (saw a trailer yesterday)

Was it any good? Did it make you think "wow, maybe this film is going to be
good" or was it just a lot of pretty FX?

DO> and The Prisoner remakes.

Hmm, I've got *very* strong doubts about this one. I don't really think that
it should be remade, it could never capture the style of the original.

DO> I may even go and see Steve Martin in Sgt Bilko.

I've seen a trailer and I think that Phil Silvers did it better (even if he
did play to his ego too much).

DO> The Addams Family was good stuff.

I'm really undecided about this one. I had the feeling that they were trying
just a bit *too* hard to make it work.

DO> Nah, the market for remakes isn't tapped out yet.

Pity...

DO> Where is the Blakes 7 remake, that's what I want to know.

Bring back Blakes 7!!!

 GM> I would *love* to see what Johnny Mnemonic would have been like had
 GM> they used Gibson's story and characterisations.

DO> Gibson was involved with that film from the beginning.

He was???? I am *extremely* surprised by that! Ok, they had to change bits
around to put it on the screen (and for copyright reasons), but why on earth
did he let them (or he put in himself) the ridiculous and dire "my head's
going to explode if I don't get rid of this information" plot and the total
wimp of a character who took Molly's place?

DO> In an interview he is very enthusiastic about it. I think the blame has
DO> to be laid at his door as much as anyone's.

I really expected better of him than this.

 DO>  The horror genre is dead on its feet too.
 GM> I don't particularly go for horror.

DO>  It's understandable that the more gory end has gone down the
DO> straight-to-video route - there are only so many ways you can cut up a
DO> latex corpse.

I thought that was "The Roswell Incident"?! ;-)

DO> The other, more thoughtful, thread in horror seems to have been killed
DO> off because Kenneth Brannagh's Frankenstein remake bombed.

Now that is a shame. Before Hammer and co got their hands on it Frankenstein
was a good story. Unfortunately it then came "Monster with bolts in its neck
terrorises population" and it *totally* loses the subtlety of the original.

 GM> The studios produce what they think that "the people want", so the
 GM> people come to expect what the studios churn out for them.

DO> Do you really think that, say, The Andromeda Strain would have
DO> outsold Jurassic Park if they had both been released on the same day?

That is an impossible question to answer. There is something like 20 years
between the two. One is a taut, thought provoking thriller, the other had a
massive advertising/ merchandising budget hyping it, there is simply no way
to compare them.

DO> Here's a thought: SF as a whole is in decline. The reason? The future
DO> is already here, and there is nothing left to write about.

And I thought that *I* was a cynic!!!

Actually that's quite an interesting point, all the "old" SF (rockets,
rayguns, robots) has been more or less superceded, even Cyberpunk (which was
a product of the '80s) seems to have faIled to come true, what is there
left to come???

DO> ... Pass that Amiga over here - this door needs to be propped open.

... Plant flowers in your Window Box and watch them grow while you wait...

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)