Slimelite BBS

Creation (was Brainy People Only)

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From John Gilbert · 1996-04-06 04:51 · #74268 in AMIGA_MAGS

In reply to Creation (was Brainy People Only) by Paul Moss

Hello Paul

02-Apr-96 13:33:18, Paul Moss wrote to John Gilbert
 Subject: Creation (was Brainy People Only)

 JG>> When putting forward this kind of argument the creationist comes comes
 JG>> up against two enormous bodies of evidence; the fossil record and the
 JG>> astronomical data. All they can do in the light of science is to claim
 JG>> that God gave us science in order to test our faith. If God is nothing
 JG>> without faith then this was a remarkably unwise experiment.

 PM> well, the fossil record just goes to disprove the dating methods
 PM> as, if we assume a steady rate of deposition (and deposition as the
 PM> only sedimentary process) then this fails to explain a) why the same
 PM> fossils occur at different depths b) why the radio-carbon dating
 PM> disagrees with the rate of deposition c) why whole animals or trees
 PM> can be fossilised upright... etc etc - at least in the words of the
 PM> book!

a) It's the stratum they are found in which matters, not the depth.
b) C14 dating only works for about 70000 years, ruling out its usage for
most fossils.
c) Animals fall into tar pits, trees are petrified following climate
change.

 PM> and astronomical data ? well, neutrino storms will change the
 PM> amounts of radioactive carbon in the atmosphere and hence invalidate
 PM> the results of radiocarbon dating!

What I meant was, if the heavens and the Earth were created at the same
time, and that time was say 10000 years ago, then we would not be able
to see anything that was more than 10000 light years away. But we can.

 JG>> I would be interested to hear your thoughts on this book when you have
 JG>> finished it.

 PM> a typical strawman argument - show that 'evolutionists' believe
 PM> this (assert a set of beliefs as a viewpoint adopted by all)... state
 PM> that some people do not agree (robert jay gould, lamarck etc) and
 PM> demolish not *what* your opponent proposes... but what you say he
 PM> claims...

The usual sort of thing then. I recently saw, but did not get a chance
to read, a magazine put out by one of those American churches. On the
cover it claimed to contain an article telling loyal followers how  to
counter all the arguments put forward by evolutionists. If anyone in
here saw it I would love to hear about it.

 .+'''+.  ð  Be Seeing You.
 J O H N  ð
 `+,,,+'  ð  Internet   John@skiesare.demon.co.uk


... God gives the nuts, but He does not crack them.                             
___ TagDude 0.86 [Unregistered] with 7742 taglines.
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
 * Origin: ð The Green Dome ð Off The Lightning BBS ð . (2:2504/100.4)