Slimelite BBS

Creation (was Brainy People Only)

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From Paul Moss · 1996-04-02 19:33 · #74194 in AMIGA_MAGS

Greetings!

Recently You Wrote

 PM>> after all, the methods used to date things are inaccurate (not
 PM>> precise) or even worse, related to other methods (!) and therefore we
 PM>> have no actual verification that the earth is older than about...
 PM>> say... ten thousand years old...

 JG> When putting forward this kind of argument the creationist comes comes 
 JG> up against two enormous bodies of evidence; the fossil record and the 
 JG> astronomical data. All they can do in the light of science is to claim 
 JG> that God gave us science in order to test our faith. If God is nothing 
 JG> without faith then this was a remarkably unwise experiment.

 well, the fossil record just goes to disprove the dating methods as, if we
 assume a steady rate of deposition (and deposition as the only sedimentary
 process) then this fails to explain a) why the same fossils occur at
 different depths b) why the radio-carbon dating disagrees with the rate of
 deposition c) why whole animals or trees can be fossilised upright... etc 
 etc - at least in the words of the book!

 and astronomical data ? well, neutrino storms will change the amounts of
 radioactive carbon in the atmosphere and hence invalidate the results of
 radiocarbon dating!

 spotted the pattern yet ? :-)

 JG> It is good that you are reading this kind of thing and opening your self
 JG> up to all sides of the argument, this is more than I have patience for.

 a worthwhile practice - if only to spot the flaws in arguments (on both 
 sides) :-)

 JG> I would be interested to hear your thoughts on this book when you have 
 JG> finished it.

 a typical strawman argument - show that 'evolutionists' believe this (assert
 a set of beliefs as a viewpoint adopted by all)... state that some people
 do not agree (robert jay gould, lamarck etc) and demolish not *what* your
 opponent proposes... but what you say he claims...

 classics such as:

 variations within a species, by mutation, shouldn't count as mutation... 
 
 because we don't see the gradual development of units (eyes, fingers etc)
 there must be large gaps in the fossil record...

 evolution *must* take a very long time...

 'survival of the fittest' is a truism...

 not all scientists agree 100% with the argument *he* says is proposed, so
 it cannot be true! :-)

 no experiments have been conducted, or proofs given, for evolution...

 points of special interest here would be: a species adapts to fill a niche.
 population pressures lead to diversity. a change of environment or population
 will result in divergence to ease the pressure. those most fitted to a niche
 will survive best in that niche. those best fitted to a newly appearing niche
 will produce offspring who can take advantage of that niche. I refer you to
 the experimental work on the galapogos finches and the sticklebacks as related
 in "The Beak Of the Finch (Evolution in Real Time)".

 PM>> (it's "The Facts Of Life" by Richard Milton BTW)

 a nice try, that told me little I didn't already know...

Cheers

P.
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
 * Origin: A million monkeys random writing (2:2500/608.2)