Slimelite BBS

Creation (was Brainy People Only)

Back to AMIGA_MAGS

From Paul Moss · 1996-04-10 20:17 · #74380 in AMIGA_MAGS

In reply to Creation (was Brainy People Only) by John Gilbert

Greetings!

Recently You Wrote

 PM>> well, the fossil record just goes to disprove the dating methods
 PM>> as, if we assume a steady rate of deposition (and deposition as the
 PM>> only sedimentary process) then this fails to explain a) why the same
 PM>> fossils occur at different depths b) why the radio-carbon dating
 PM>> disagrees with the rate of deposition c) why whole animals or trees
 PM>> can be fossilised upright... etc etc - at least in the words of the
 PM>> book!

 JG> a) It's the stratum they are found in which matters, not the depth.
 
 but *he* claims that heologists say deposition is uniform... and why isn't
 there a lot more moondust cos it ought to be over 70 metres deep...

 JG> b) C14 dating only works for about 70000 years, ruling out its usage for
 JG> most fossils.

 which is, he says, why we should discard it...

 JG> c) Animals fall into tar pits, trees are petrified following climate
 JG> change.

 apparently he hadn't heard of that! :-)

 PM>> and astronomical data ? well, neutrino storms will change the
 PM>> amounts of radioactive carbon in the atmosphere and hence invalidate
 PM>> the results of radiocarbon dating!

 JG> What I meant was, if the heavens and the Earth were created at the same
 JG> time, and that time was say 10000 years ago, then we would not be able
 JG> to see anything that was more than 10000 light years away. But we can.

 oh no, we only *think* we can...

 and he doesn't bother to mention astronomy...

 JG>>> I would be interested to hear your thoughts on this book when you have
 JG>>> finished it.

 a typical strawman argument, deeply flawed, with sufficient real evidence
 and manner to convince the unwary (ie those who do not have a fairly detailed
 knowledge of several areas of science)...

 laughable if you *do* know what he's talking about...

 but, like velikovsky and von daniken, points out anomolies that you *should*
 be aware of...

 JG> The usual sort of thing then. I recently saw, but did not get a chance
 JG> to read, a magazine put out by one of those American churches. On the
 JG> cover it claimed to contain an article telling loyal followers how  to
 JG> counter all the arguments put forward by evolutionists. If anyone in
 JG> here saw it I would love to hear about it.

 as would I...

Cheers

P.
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
 * Origin: Home of the Electric Shepherd (2:2500/608.2)