Slimelite BBS

Tigana

Back to PRATCHETT

From Robert Bull · 1996-04-14 01:50 · #74113 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Clive Barker: Weaveworld by Richard Romanowski

Hello, Richard;

10 Apr 96 14:30, Richard Romanowski wrote to Robert Bull:

 RB>> ;-)  Much as I enjoyed "Tigana," I wasn't as overboard as most
 RB>> people in  the echo...

 RR> That's one of the books I've got awaiting assimilation. |+) Could you
 RR> compare it to anything else you've read ?

Not really.  That, BTW, is something of a compliment.  It is very good, it 
just isn't quite _like_ anything else.  Where it does dip from the well of 
common myth, it takes uncommon parts of it; no elves, but a riselka, for 
example.  The "feel" is much more of an adventure story set in an 
Italianate landscape rather than anything close to Tolkienesque, and all 
the better for it.  It is an origianal, not an exploitation, mere formula 
writing.  Perhaps it's so popular because it's more appropriate to our 
times, with less belief in the supernatural than earlier centuries.  Or I 
could be having another flight of fancy, of course.

 RB>> Haven't seen any other messages about "Weaveworld"
 RR> They've all been singing it's praises...

Hmmm, have to read it one day I suppose, if I can find a copy.

 RB>> ...as I haven't been following the echo lately...

 RR> Tsk, tsk ! How dare you have a life outside F&SF ! |+)

<grin> I never said altogether outside Fidonet.  But, sadly, I have to cut 
down on Fidonetting and reading during the summer.

     Regards,

              Robert.

--- GoldED 2.50+
 * Origin: Pointing at Minerva * 28 lines/12Gigs * 0181-402-3350 (2:254/33.4)