From David Otton · 1996-04-14 10:22 · #74114 in PRATCHETT
-=> Quoting Graham Marsden to David Otton <=- Hi Graham, GM> Are you trying to tell me that *no* SF films (or very few) have GM> managed to include characters that are more than two dimensional? Hmm. Yeah, I think I can argue for that. Mainly because SF isn't about characters, they don't really matter. It's about ideas (usually technological), and playing with them. Of course, we all know there are exceptions to every rule. DO> Using your bare bones trick, I can dismiss just about all of the SF DO> films out there. GM> Possibly, but you have to be careful not to take away some of the GM> bones whilst you are doing it. Well, lets see what bones you missed out in T2. We have the standard hubris plot so beloved of SF, along with a corny "greater love hath no man" ending, and, curiously, an anti-technology feel about the whole thing. It ain't just explosions. GM> eg Alien would, as has been said, a simple "chase the monster" movie GM> if it wasn't for the fact that there was the sub plot of the Company's GM> motives and that characters like Riply have an existance outside of the GM> film. Actually, the characters in Alien were very flat. They didn't get along with each other, but so what? Ripley wasn't really fleshed out until Aliens, and even then not by much. GM> [Re: The Andromeda Strain] GM> As for the plot, again I think you're taking the bare bones bit too GM> far and losing a bone or too. We have the basic plot of "superbug GM> threatens mankind", ok, pretty standard. But then we find that, like GM> The Day of the Triffids, mankind might well have been the architect of GM> his own destruction. Hubris again. It actually compares rather well with T2. GM> We also find that as well as being designed to protect mankind, the GM> Wildfire project was designed to research methods of destroying men. GM> *This* is the sort of thing that sets it apart from the usual stuff. You mean like Skynet, designed to protect people, turning on its creators? GM> As to "it hasn't aged very well", I suppose, looking at it now, it GM> does look a bit cliched, but you could say that LOTR looks cliched now GM> because so many people have copied it. That isn't the fault of the GM> original. Ner. S'just that techniques improve, that is to be expected, and I would be worried if they didn't. DO> I think that what you are doing here is saying "this is what I like, DO> this is SF", and attacking the rest for not being what you like. GM> No, I don't think I've done that at all. For instance I like Star Wars GM> as good old fashioned "the good guys win, the bad guys lose" stuff, but GM> I acknowledge that that is *all* that it is. Then like is the wrong word. These are the films you think are in some sense worthy? GM> Phase IV, another good one. DO> Has the same problems. I reckon it is because it is a product of the 70s DO> [...] amongst other things that took themselves too seriously. GM> Eh? I think you have that backwards. Like 2001 it shows how *man* is GM> taking himself too seriously in thinking that he has all the answers. Ok, 2001 is a film with a "big" message. I don't think that makes it in any way better than T2 or Jurassic Park, in fact, box office takings are probably a better indicator of quality. If I was bankrolling a film, that is what I would be interested in. GM> 2001 showed him that there was a huge universe out there which was GM> beyond his comprehension, Phase IV went the other way and showed him GM> how little he knew about his own world. Yup, showed. But I thought you didn't like things with messages and morals? [TNG] DO> The Philidelphia Experiment GM> I'm sorry, but I found the whole film laughable and *very* cliched. GM> And the special effects were pretty naff too. Well I liked it. Probably the most consistent time travel movie there is. [What's the one with a modern-day aircraft carrier being sucked back to Pearl Harbour?] GM> Silent Running GM> I don't think you can compare the two. SW's only purpose was GM> entertainment, it made no pretensions of having any deeper meaning. SR, GM> OTOH, was about man's attitude to his planet, the fact that it was set GM> out in space emphasised the point. Again, having a message doesn't make it better. GM> Star Wars was the first example of this sort of film and represented a GM> quantum leap in the way that SF films were made and presented. DO> So did 2001? GM> Yes, but the leap was in a different direction. A direction you think is better, but with what evidence? GM> In SW it was the special effects that drove the film. Not convinced. Agreed, the FX made the film, but the wizard's tower scenario is fine by me. (I /like/ rollercoaster rides). DO> [Quantum leap - just about the smallest leap that it is possible DO> to make. Sorry, but it annoys me.] GM> Err, but isn't it from the use in Physics of when an electron or atom GM> changes from one energy state to a new one? Yup. A very small change indeed. GM> call me a cynic, but I think it goes "look at all the special effects GM> we can do. Let's get someone to write a story so we can use them!" DO> Wotsisname intended to use traditional techniques to make Jurassic Park DO> they convinced him to try computer animation once the project was DO> already up and running. GM> Ok, maybe that's an exception, but too many other films seem to work GM> the other way around. ISTR that the FX techniques in SW were developed as the film was being made. The same goes for the digitised sequence in Westworld. As this seems to be your central argument, you don't seem to be offering up much evidence for it. GM> [Re: Dr Who] GM> Oh yes, *that* trailer. It *really* makes you want to see the film, GM> doesn't it? How long is it? Five seconds...? Actually, yeah, it does. And I hate Dr Who normally... DO> ...Blakes 7... DO> Look, you've been in denial long enough. They are /never/ going DO> to show it again. GM> Hah! I've seen it all on Bravo!! And I missed it. Sob. I want a see-through PC with lots of flashing lights inside. GM> why on earth did he let them put the ridiculous and dire "my head's GM> going to explode if I don't get rid of this information" plot DO> Because he is ignorant of technology? GM> Come on! Even someone who is *totally* ignorant is going to go for GM> that one, are they? Are they??? Thirty percent of people cannot describe the relative positions of the Sun, Moon and Earth. Sound in space. Wargames. Lawnmower man. The bit in Moonraker where the shuttle is skipping along the top of the atmosphere. Need I go on? GM> No, even with the stuff you added below it's not possible. It's like GM> asking which of True Lies or Four Welders and a Futon (umm, sorry, Four GM> Weddings and a Funeral) would outsell each other. Wasn't 4Weddings a rather big hit? And True Lies a massive flop... although that could be your point...? GM> One is a mass market all-action spectacular, the other an interesting GM> story about a number of characters. They can't be compared. I suggest that popularity, measured in money earned, is the /only/ way to compare two films, because everything else is subjective. GM> Which gets more viewers, Coronation GM> Street or Kavanagh QC? Which is the "better" of the two? Coronation Street. I don't think so (well, I don't watch either of them), but I only get one vote. GM> I forget who said it, but one scientist said (sometime around the turn GM> of the 20th century I think) that he was going to get out of science GM> because "everything has already been invented"!! I've heard something like that before - there were a few months when it did look like the whole of physics was almost sewn up - just before QM started to unfold... GM> He was wrong and, with respect, I think you are too. (Maybe we should GM> start a thread about future trends in SF? But in a different message!) I'll leave that to someone else. It's not a position I necessarily agree with, just an idea. In fact, I don't agree with a lot of what I say. DO> BTW, I thought of another one that messes up your chronology - Brazil. GM> I don't recall that one. Perhaps a few details...? Bloody brilliant film. I'd offer to lend you a copy, but I taped over it :~( Think 1984, with an ending like a kick in the guts. Highlights include Bob Hoskins playing a plumber who isn't called Mario. DO> Better than all those 70s films, too. And Scanners, which I don't like DO> much. And where would The Lost Boys or The Witches of Eastwick fit? GM> To be honest I don't think any of them fit comfortably into the SF GM> genre, they are more of the Horror/ Fantasy style of stories. Nuffin wrong with Scanners, but I'll have Barbarella instead. Now tell me SF is getting steadily worse... GM> Possibly in the case of Batman, but I think Alien stands up well GM> enough in the SF genre. Nah. S'a horror film. Replace the space ship with a sea-faring container ship and you still have exactly the same film. GM> I forget where I've seen or read it, but 12:01 (and Groundhog Day) GM> were both very like a story I read from back in (at a guess) the '60s. GM> Remakes don't exactly count. Same idea, different interpretation. It counts, or anything that bears a passing resemblance to something else can be thrown out. Some of that may not be too coherent, I'm afraid. Terminal fatigue :( |)/\\/||) ... Behind every satisfied blonde is a line of exhausted men. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)