From Caroline Bourne · 1996-04-14 14:21 · #74112 in PRATCHETT
In reply to Sci-Fi Movies by Graham Marsden
Hello there MS> Here's a message I just posted into IMAGES which is quite relevant MS> to our recent discussion. I've replaced the "colourful metaphors". > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ GM> A follow up to this. Caroline Bourne, who you may have seen in this echo, GM> has a 12 year old daughter who messages in Pratchett.. OY! That's me you are talking about! Are you a mind reader? I fixed out of 'IMAGES' months ago because it seemed that language-wise it was a case of 'anything goes'. GM> ..if I had a child of that age I think I would take exception to them GM> reading an echo where the messages were sprinkled with obscenities. Yep. I take exception to /me/ reading it too. I've actually twitted someone in 'Punch' who posted a piece of unmitigated filth. GM> Anyway, back to the thread... MS> The problem is, where sci-fi is concerned, that producers/directors seem MS> to be too concerned about converting and adapting and not actually MS> creating something *specifically* for the cinema. Like Star Wars? MS> The fact of the matter is that the best sci-fi exists in literature. GM> Agreed. I agree too. Even though my first intro to the genre was watching Dr Who from behind the sofa. MS> Now, whereas other genres can be quite adequately converted to the big MS> screen without losing an awful lot, sci-fi novels are something MS> completely different. If you like, sci-fi's literary origins are part of MS> its genetic make-up and if you start shoveling everything onto the big MS> screen, you're going to get nowhere. Yes but the trouble is that Sci-Fi spans other genre's. You can get horror, like Aliens; Mysteries, like 'The Caves of Steel' etc. Westerns, like Star Wars. (Spaceships instead of horses, but otherwise a fairly basic Farm-boy makes good tale); Comedy, like Red Dwarf... GM> Again, I'm not sure that I agree. I think the problem *is* with SF's GM> literary origins, but because in a novel you can leave what things look GM> like to the reader's imagination, whereas, on screen, you GM> *have* to show it. Hmm. I've finished TCOS now. I can't think why I didn't read it years ago, when I read the follow up (The Naked Sun). Anyway, IMO you wouldn't need very expensive special effects to make TCOS work on film. You'd need hundreds of identically dressed extras, but special effects could be minimal. TNS could be VERY expensive though. The Earth Robots in the book would be, I imagine, a bit like a cross between C3PO and Daleks, acting like moronic slaves :-) MS> What producers need to do is create sci-fi with the cinematic MS> medium in mind. Look at the most successful sci-fi movies of the MS> past few decades -- 2001, Star Wars, Blade Runner and The Abyss. MS> All of them were produced *for* the cinema. I got the book of Star Wars. Read it in two hours at the age of 14. Not a good book. Note. that last bit is being considered for 'my Understatement of the year award' ;-) GM> Yes, they were written specifically for the cinema, however 2001 and Blade GM> Runner had their plots written *before* they were filmed. Like Babylon 5. GM> Too many other films either seem to get all the special effects done and GM> then worry about putting a plot in, Like Star Trek? MS> And here you get the other problem -- with the fans. Most sci-fi MS> fans only seem to read sci-fi and not much else. GM> but I find most "standard" fiction to be basically pretty boring or GM> self indulgent (eg murder mysteries are simply written for murder GM> mystery fans). Have you read any SF Murder mysteries? What did you think of them? (Has anyone other than Asimov written any?) Shall we discuss this in another thread? MS> They'll also read books first and go to the cinema second. Books are better value for money, especially if you have a library ticket. GM> Not necessarily, but... When was the last time you went to the Cinema? How many times have you been in the last year? OTOH, how many books have you read in the last year? GM> Yes, but it's a vicious circle, IMO. There have been so many bad film GM> adaptions of good books And not just in SF :-( GM> that the SF fan would prefer to read the book before they see the film. GM> So if the novelisation is trite and boring with no plot or depth to the GM> characters and the only thing to recommend the film are the special GM> effects, then why bother going to watch the film. At cinema prices? MS> I personally reckon the next 'Star Wars' movie will blow every other MS> film away when it's released GM> Will it? Will we actually get *characters* instead of cardboard cut outs? GM> Will we get a plot better than "rescue the princess in the tower"? If they do it properly, it does have potential. What sort of person was Luke's dad before he became Darth Vader? Exactly how did he become seduced by the dark side of the Force? I even think there is room for a strong female lead too, in the person of Luke's mother. ttfn Caroline --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: Klatchian Curry Gardens (2:440/601.12)