From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-11 07:02 · #74029 in PRATCHETT
Hi Mark,
MS> Here's a message I just posted into IMAGES which is quite relevant
MS> to our recent discussion. I've replaced the "colourful metaphors".
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
A follow up to this. Caroline Bourne, who you may have seen in this echo,
has a 12 year old daughter who messages in Pratchett (amongst other places).
Now I don't know about you, but if I had a child of that age I think I would
take exception to them reading an echo where the messages were sprinkled
with obscenities.
Anyway, back to the thread...
[Re: Strange Days, The Abyss & Blade Runner]
AB> My money's on The Abyss too I'm afraid. Strange days is an okay film,
AB> but it just doesn't have classic written all over it unlike the other
AB> two.
MS> The lack of decent sci-fi films is currently being discussed on
MS> the F&SF.UK echo,
Hey, fame at last! (Or is it infamy?) (Do they all have it infamy?? ;-) )
MS> The problem is, where sci-fi is concerned, that producers/directors seem
MS> to be too concerned about converting and adapting and not actually
MS> creating something *specifically* for the cinema.
Really? I would have thought that it was the other way round. IMO they are
too busy creating something to look good on the cinema screen that they
totally forget about the minor details of plots and characterisations.
MS> The fact of the matter is that the best sci-fi exists in literature.
Agreed.
MS> Now, whereas other genres can be quite adequately converted to the big
MS> screen without losing an awful lot, sci-fi novels are something
MS> completely different. If you like, sci-fi's literary origins are part of
MS> its genetic make-up and if you start shoveling everything onto the big
MS> screen, you're going to get nowhere.
Again, I'm not sure that I agree. I think the problem *is* with SF's
literary origins, but because in a novel you can leave what things look like
to the reader's imagination, whereas, on screen, you *have* to show it.
MS> What producers need to do is create sci-fi with the cinematic
MS> medium in mind. Look at the most successful sci-fi movies of the
MS> past few decades -- 2001, Star Wars, Blade Runner and The Abyss.
MS> All of them were produced *for* the cinema.
Yes, they were written specifically for the cinema, however 2001 and Blade
Runner had their plots written *before* they were filmed. Too many other
films either seem to get all the special effects done and then worry about
putting a plot in, or having a plot written *specifically* so that they can
use all the effects they want which, IMO, was the category into which I
would put Star Wars and The Abyss.
Just as a sub point here, I wasn't actually too impressed by The Abyss, but
I've only ever seen it once and I prefer to watch films twice so that I can
appreciate the "craftsmanship" on the second viewing.
MS> And here you get the other problem -- with the fans. Most sci-fi
MS> fans only seem to read sci-fi and not much else.
And Fantasy, but, ok, it's a good point. Although I do tend to read
"Technothrillers", eg Tom Clancy, Desmond Bagley etc, but I find most
"standard" fiction to be basically pretty boring or self indulgent (eg
murder mysteries are simply written for murder mystery fans).
MS> They'll also read books first and go to the cinema second.
Not necessarily, but...
MS> So what happens when something like 'Strange Days' appears at the
MS> cinema? The first thing they do is go out and buy the novelisation --
MS> "to see what the film's like". Obviously, the novelisation is [poo]
MS> because 'Strange Days' is meant to be a film, not a novel, and the
MS> sci-fi pundit walks away going, "Well, Strange Days was [poo]"
MS> without even having seen the film.
Yes, but it's a vicious circle, IMO. There have been so many bad film
adaptions of good books that the SF fan would prefer to read the book before
they see the film. So if the novelisation is trite and boring with no plot
or depth to the characters and the only thing to recommend the film are
the special effects, then why bother going to watch the film.
MS> So here you have the problem -- the sci-fi fan prefers literature
MS> and the producers don't know how to make good cinematic sci-fi
MS> Once in a blue moon you get a decent classic -- it's just a pity
MS> they're all too rare. I mean, take a look at the past few decades
MS> -- they only really boast one decent sci-fi movie each:
MS> 1960s 2001
MS> 1970s Star Wars (possibly Alien too)
MS> 1980s Blade Runner
MS> 1990s The Abyss
I'm trying to think of other good SF films, but it's getting late and I
can't think of any off the top of my head except for The Andromeda Strain.
I'm *really* going to have to get one of those "Encyclopaedia of Science
Fiction" books to help me in arguments like this!!
MS> All four (five) of them are not only decent sci-fi, but they're
MS> decent movies too and actually build on the genre, rather than
MS> just being part of it.
I would disagree with Star Wars, but we're covering that elsewhere and I'm
not too sure about The Abyss, but I certainly agree about 2001, Alien and
Blade Runner.
MS> It's quite depressing though, knowing that we're probably only gonna get
MS> one decent sci-fi movie a decade -- perhaps two if we're lucky.
Agreed. :-(
MS> Now, I'm not saying that things like 'T2' and 'Jurassic Park' are [poo]
MS> - I think they're great -- but they're not *progressive*.
They were "progressive" only in terms of the special effects used, not in
terms of quality films.
MS> Other genres fair a lot better -- there's much more rapid progress
MS> and more classics to boast of. Look at the gangster movie -- in
MS> the past few years we've already had Goodfellas, Reservoir Dogs,
MS> Carlito's Way, Pulp Fiction, The Usual Suspects and Casino, each
MS> one nudging the genre just that little bit further forward.
Hmm, some people might argue that they've pushed the genre *too* far
forward, but I can't really comment as I haven't seen any of these, simply
because they don't appeal to me.
MS> It's a shame -- sci-fi is capable of doing this.
Definitely!
MS> There should be more Blade Runners and 2001s,
Hear hear!
MS> but there aren't.
Boo, hiss!
MS> Come December 31st 1999 when we're all sitting around this echo going,
MS> "What was the best sci-fi movie of the 90s then?" what are we going to
MS> come up with?
Well, it ain't going to be Johnny Mnemonic or Judge Dredd...!
MS> Hopefully George Lucas and Stanley Kubrick will give us a few more
MS> candidates.
I don't know about Lucas, I think he's been to seduced by the "mass market"
appeal. Kubrik, possibly, but he's getting on a bit now, isn't he?
MS> I personally reckon the next 'Star Wars' movie will blow every other
MS> film away when it's released
Will it? Will we actually get *characters* instead of cardboard cut outs?
Will we get a plot better than "rescue the princess in the tower"?
MS> I'm praying that Kubrick's 'AI' will do another '2001'. It's about time.
If you have heard anything on the making of this I'm sure people in here
would be interested in hearing it (with adequate spoiler protection, of
course!)
Ah, hang on, I've just pressed the right arrow and what do I find, but a
posting from you with info on Star Wars 4...! You must be psychic! ;-)
Although, having just read the message, I'm not particularly impressed with
what seems to be Lucas' concentrating on getting all the effects to look
impressive, rather than worrying about the plot and characters.
Cheers,
Graham.
--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
* Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)