Slimelite BBS

Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-13 00:12 · #74076 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Paul Walker

Hi Graham,

Quoting Graham Marsden to Paul Walker, on 09 Apr 96  16:35:00,
about Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!.

[Andromeda Strain]
 GM> The film is a *very* good adaption of the book. Very little is changed
 GM> and it sticks to the excellent plot in almost every detail.

Excellent? But what about the unresolved bit, at the end? Didn't that annoy
you? Didn't you say "Well, it's an unresolved plot thread, they should have
made a sequel?" ;-)
 
 PW> but I've got the book, and it wasn't that good, TBH.
 GM> Hmm, personal preference, but I found it chillingly plausible. What
 GM> *really* got to me was the bibliography in the back of all sorts of
 GM> medical texts and reference works.

Well, yes. But anyone can list references etc in the back. All he used those
for were for the technology, I would imagine. The book itself is fiction.
 
 PW> I'd still rather have a book, than a film, anyway! <g>
 GM> Possibly I would too, however you have to admit that films have more
 GM> mass market appeal than books these days.

I'm not arguing that, I'm just saying I prefer a book (for nearly all things,
anyway).

[FX and plot] 
 PW> In the case of Star Wars, I don't think you can separate them that
 PW> easily - they both combine to make the film, neither one having the
 GM> Eh? If you took away the special effects, right from the opening
 GM> "scrolling text" and the Rebel Blockade Runner being chased by that
 GM> *massive* Star Destroyer which looms over your head to the final
 GM> climactic battle, what have you got left in Star Wars?

Okay then, we'll do this to your favourite example - 2001.

What are we left with? A group of monkey's messing around. This scene then
changes to a space station (but not with the bone sequence, remember, because
that's FX. And you can't see the outside of the station, for the same reason).
Then an expedition is mounted to the moon of one of the planets (can't remember
which). You wouldn't have any of the outside shots, or the weightless shots,
as that's FX. And the whole end bit would be removed altogether (which might
make it a bit clearer! <g>)

So, what it boils down to is this - man starts off as a monkey, works up to
a space traveller, finds he isn't alone, and goes off to try to meet the 
aliens.

And you're telling me *that's* an original plot?

 GM> Basically it is incredibly cliched Fantasy stuff with no depth of plot
 GM> or characterisations, only the special effects make this film any
 GM> different. 

Yes, but it *is* different. Anyway, it's done now - what's the point in
arguing about it? (Until they invent time travel, of course... ;-)

And you have to ask yourself, how many of the current, good SF films would 
there be if George Lucas hadn't made it profitable to create one? (BR goes
out of the window, for a start)

 _
|_)                      
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... Never feed your cat anything that doesn't match the carpet.
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)