Slimelite BBS

Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-13 00:16 · #74077 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Paul Walker

Hi Graham,

Quoting Graham Marsden to Ray Barker, on 09 Apr 96  18:28:23,
about Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!.

[Unintelligible <sp?> ending of 2001]
 RB> _Surely_ that is not the mark of a good film?
 GM> That depends whether you like having your drama spoonfed to you with
 GM> nice explanations for the hard of thinking, or whether you like
 GM> something which leaves you thinking.

Oh, come on. You wheel out this excuse every time. So if a film is clear
and reasonably easy to follow, the people who like it are hard of thinking - 
if the ending of a film is really hard to understand, the people who like it
are "true" SF fans? (I'm sorry, I'm still annoyed over the "real" SF bit 
earlier)
 
 RB> (I like /most/ of it, but surely my point about the end is one that
 RB> most agree with...)

I'll back you up here, Ray :-)

[snip]
 GM> The ape-man discovers that, far from being "master of all he surveys"
 GM> he is, in fact, less than a baby in terms of the cosmos.

And you got this from the ending, did you? Well done. I certainly couldn't 
have done, if I hadn't read the book first.

 GM> The only point in the film which I feel could have been made clearer
 GM> was that in the four million year "flash forward", the bone becomes an
 GM> orbiting nuclear bomb, pointing out how the ape-man was shown how to

I thought it was the space station? ICBW, though.
 _
|_)                      
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... Money will not buy happiness, but it will let you be unha
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)