Slimelite BBS

Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Paul Walker · 1996-04-13 00:05 · #74075 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Paul Walker

Hi Graham,

Quoting Graham Marsden to Ian Muirhead, on 07 Apr 96  16:11:21,
about Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!.
 
 GM> That is, IMO, the problem. Big budget FX fests like Star Wars have
 GM> become associated with with SF in the public's minds, so when they
 GM> encounter "real" SF they can't cope with it or understand it.

Now *THAT* is arrogance. Define real SF. Cerebral? To you, maybe. However, to
the "public" it is Star Wars. Who is to say that your definition is more
accurate?
 
 GM> But it still doesn't get away from the point that a short story can
 GM> create perfectly adequate or even excellent characters and plots in
 GM> very few pages, so why is it so hard for films to emulate this?

Because it's easier to use words to set up a plot than film - in a book, you
can go "inside" a character's head, and so on. Trying to do that in a film
just doesn't work (for example, Dune).

 _
|_)                      
|  aul                   paul.walker@esoftc.seuk.com     <No files>

... Consider your reputation.  Try changing your name and mov
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Highlander BB's - Gloucester [ +44-1452-384702/557 ] (2:253/418)