Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-10 02:35 · #73955 in PRATCHETT

Hi Paul,

 GM> there is something more than special effects which turns any particular
 GM> suspense film into, say, The Andromeda Strain.

PW> Don't know about the film,

The film is a *very* good adaption of the book. Very little is changed and
it sticks to the excellent plot in almost every detail.

PW> but I've got the book, and it wasn't that good, TBH.

Hmm, personal preference, but I found it chillingly plausible. What *really*
got to me was the bibliography in the back of all sorts of medical texts and
reference works.

 GM> IMO the SF film is a dying breed but that no one has yet noticed
 GM> because they can't see that it is all superficiality and no depth.

PW> I'd still rather have a book, than a film, anyway! <g>

Possibly I would too, however you have to admit that films have more mass
market appeal than books these days.

 GM> There *have* been SF films which haven't relied on flashy special
 GM> effects, eg 2001: A Space Odyssey where the effects were so good that
 GM> they could be ignored (for the most part).

PW> Hmm. They cocked the ending up a bit, though, didn't they? In
PW> fact, a lot! :)

I said "for the most part". Yes, of course, at the end, there was a whole
lot of special effects, however the plot did not *rely* on them, nor were
they necessary to make it an excellent film. They were the icing on the
cake, they weren't the cake itself.

 GM> the effects were almost *deliberately* emphasised to distract from
 GM> the shallowness of the plot and characters.

PW> In the case of Star Wars, I don't think you can separate them that
PW> easily - they both combine to make the film, neither one having the
PW> "upper hand", as it were.

Eh? If you took away the special effects, right from the opening "scrolling
text" and the Rebel Blockade Runner being chased by that *massive* Star
Destroyer which looms over your head to the final climactic battle, what
have you got left in Star Wars?

Princess captured by Evil Baddie, Poor Farm Boy sets off to rescue her,
meets Assorted Motley Companions, rescues Princess and saves the day!

Basically it is incredibly cliched Fantasy stuff with no depth of plot or
characterisations, only the special effects make this film any different.

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)