Slimelite BBS

Re: Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Eoghann Irving · 1996-04-12 03:16 · #74018 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Graham Marsden

It was 09 Apr 96 when Graham Marsden turned to Paul Walker and uttered these fatefull words:

 
 GM> Eh? If you took away the special effects, right from the opening
 GM> "scrolling text" and the Rebel Blockade Runner being chased by that
 GM> *massive* Star Destroyer which looms over your head to the final
 GM> climactic battle, what have you got left in Star Wars?

 GM> Basically it is incredibly cliched Fantasy stuff with no depth of plot
 GM> or characterisations, only the special effects make this film any
 GM> different.


I'd agree that the basic plot of Star Wars is a cliche.  It was always  intended to be I think.  But there is one element your forgetting which is at least as important as the special effects.  The dialogue.  The characters may not be very original or deep, but they *are* fun to listen to. :)


Have Fun,


Eoghann

     ************************************************************
     ***   New SUPER SIZZLE.  It's SO good we ate the baby!   ***
     ************************************************************

--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: A deeply distrubed mind (2:440/302.14@FidoNet)