From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-08 02:11 · #73954 in PRATCHETT
Hi Ian, IM>> Ok, shoot... IM> <<<*BANG*!!!>>>> Oops, sorry, we've done that gag already, haven't we? IM> Yep :) "Yeah, but it was fun though, wasn't it?" "Yeah, let's do it again!" [Shooty and Bang Bang from the Hitch Hiker's Guide...!] [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] IM>> it sure got a lot of new fans interested in SF... GM> But *what sort* of SF did they get interested in? The glitzy big GM> box office spectacular SF or the *real* SF with depth and content? IM> Hmm, I think if you did show some real SF to some SF film fans IM> they would run a mile :) That is, IMO, the problem. Big budget FX fests like Star Wars have become associated with with SF in the public's minds, so when they encounter "real" SF they can't cope with it or understand it. IM>> nearly all big films now have big sets and budgets, not just SF, GM> a big budget and a big name star doesn't guarantee a good film, GM> does it? (Remember Waterworld??) IM> 'Waterworld' wasn't a /bad/ film as such, it just had all the elements IM> of a hollywod action film, and thats what the punters went to see That is another problem (or the same one from a different viewpoint). SF films don't *have* to be action films, but that is what is expected, so that is what is produced. It's a vicious circle which doesn't benefit the genre. [Re: the SF film is a dying breed] IM>> There never has been a lot of depth in an SF film, nor in any normal IM>> length film, there simply is not the time to explain everything... GM> So how come Gibson can create a story like Johnny Mnemonic in *twenty GM> two pages*, yet Hollywood squanders the storyline in favour of masses GM> of effects? IM> It is an extreme example however, JM was /very/ bad, I wonder if that is because those of us who know what Gibson is capable of felt so let down by this film? But it still doesn't get away from the point that a short story can create perfectly adequate or even excellent characters and plots in very few pages, so why is it so hard for films to emulate this? Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)