From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-08 02:16 · #73953 in PRATCHETT
Hi David, [Re: Depth of books vs films] GM> you can put more detail into books because they don't have to run for GM> 90 minutes, but surely there have been plenty of films which have GM> managed to include depth. DO> I don't think there have. Are you trying to tell me that *no* SF films (or very few) have managed to include characters that are more than two dimensional? They have not managed to produce plots which aren't completely linear and obvious? DO> Using your bare bones trick, I can dismiss just about all of the SF DO> films out there. Possibly, but you have to be careful not to take away some of the bones whilst you are doing it. eg Alien would, as has been said, a simple "chase the monster" movie if it wasn't for the fact that there was the sub plot of the Company's motives and that characters like Riply have an existance outside of the film. DO> Anyway, SF isn't really suited to film. Hmm, that almost bears posting as a topic on its own! This, of course, depends on your definition of SF. The sort of SF that relies on "rockets, rayguns and robots" is *eminently* suited to film. The Gibsonesque style, however, probably isn't. [Re: The Andromeda Strain] DO> I've been thinking about this, and it isn't a very good film. It is very DO> loose (you could cut 20mins out of it with no problems at all) and the DO> plot is lifted straight from a 50s B movie (especially the ending). In DO> general, it hasn't aged very well. I'm not so sure. Maybe there is a bit of wasted time and space, but I think that 20 minutes is excessive. There is no excessive dwelling on irrelevant detail and the detail which is dwelt on is not overdone. As for the plot, again I think you're taking the bare bones bit too far and losing a bone or too. We have the basic plot of "superbug threatens mankind", ok, pretty standard. But then we find that, like The Day of the Triffids, mankind might well have been the architect of his own destruction. We also find that as well as being designed to protect mankind, the Wildfire project was designed to research methods of destroying men. *This* is the sort of thing that sets it apart from the usual stuff. As to "it hasn't aged very well", I suppose, looking at it now, it does look a bit cliched, but you could say that LOTR looks cliched now because so many people have copied it. That isn't the fault of the original. DO> I think that what you are doing here is saying "this is what I like, DO> this is SF", and attacking the rest for not being what you like. No, I don't think I've done that at all. For instance I like Star Wars as good old fashioned "the good guys win, the bad guys lose" stuff, but I acknowledge that that is *all* that it is. I have made no representations of what "I consider is SF", indeed, in other threads, I have gone out of my way to accept that it is a very wide topic indeed, covering such things as Horror which don't, personally, interest me. GM> Phase IV, another good one. DO> Has the same problems. I reckon it is because it is a product of the 70s DO> [...] amongst other things that took themselves too seriously. Eh? I think you have that backwards. Like 2001 it shows how *man* is taking himself too seriously in thinking that he has all the answers. 2001 showed him that there was a huge universe out there which was beyond his comprehension, Phase IV went the other way and showed him how little he knew about his own world. DO> The Philidelphia Experiment (iffy), GM> *Well* iffy!! DO> But a better film. Not great, but better. I'm sorry, but I found the whole film laughable and *very* cliched. And the special effects were pretty naff too. GM> I'm really not sure about Silent Running. Yes, it is an intelligent GM> and thought provoking film, but, IMO it just drags on too long. DO> They all do. Nobody could accuse SW of taking itself too seriously. I don't think you can compare the two. SW's only purpose was entertainment, it made no pretensions of having any deeper meaning. SR, OTOH, was about man's attitude to his planet, the fact that it was set out in space emphasised the point. GM> Star Wars was the first example of this sort of film and represented a GM> quantum leap in the way that SF films were made and presented. DO> So did 2001? Yes, but the leap was in a different direction. 2001 used lots of special effects, but the film wasn't *about* the special effects. In SW it was the special effects that drove the film. DO> [Quantum leap - just about the smallest leap that it is possible DO> to make. Sorry, but it annoys me.] Err, but isn't it from the use in Physics of when an electron or atom changes from one energy state to a new one? GM> call me a cynic, but I think it goes "look at all the special effects GM> we can do. Let's get someone to write a story so we can use them!" DO> Wotsisname intended to use traditional techniques to make Jurassic Park DO> they convinced him to try computer animation once the project was DO> already up and running. Ok, maybe that's an exception, but too many other films seem to work the other way around. [Re: Dr Who] Oh yes, *that* trailer. It *really* makes you want to see the film, doesn't it? How long is it? Five seconds...? DO> Where is the Blakes 7 remake, that's what I want to know. GM> Bring back Blakes 7!!! DO> It's like ringing a bell for one of Pavlov's dogs... <Grin> <Slobber!> DO> Look, you've been in denial long enough. They are /never/ going DO> to show it again. Hah! I've seen it all on Bravo!! [Re: Johnny Mnemonic] DO> Gibson was involved with that film from the beginning. GM> I am *extremely* surprised by that! DO> Search for wmgib10.zip on this board. I'll have to take a look at that. GM> why on earth did he let them put the ridiculous and dire "my head's GM> going to explode if I don't get rid of this information" plot DO> Because he is ignorant of technology? Come on! Even someone who is *totally* ignorant is going to go for that one, are they? Are they??? DO> Do you really think that, say, The Andromeda Strain would have DO> outsold Jurassic Park if they had both been released on the same day? GM> That is an impossible question to answer. DO> No, you're trying to avoid it. No, even with the stuff you added below it's not possible. It's like asking which of True Lies or Four Welders and a Futon (umm, sorry, Four Weddings and a Funeral) would outsell each other. One is a mass market all-action spectacular, the other an interesting story about a number of characters. They can't be compared. GM> There are 20 years between the two. One is a taut, thought provoking GM> thriller, the other had a massive advertising/ merchandising budget GM> hyping it, there is simply no way to compare them. DO> Ok, you can remake it. Modern production values, pick your own stars, DO> even FX if you want them, but you can't change the story or add CGI DO> dinosaurs. Which makes more money? It still makes no difference for the reasons given above. Anyway, box office receipts are no real measure of how "good" a film is, just which appeals to a broader audience. Which gets more viewers, Coronation Street or Kavanagh QC? Which is the "better" of the two? DO> Here's a thought: SF as a whole is in decline. The reason? The future DO> is already here, and there is nothing left to write about. GM> And I thought that *I* was a cynic!!! DO> That isn't cynicism. Anyway, its true. If we haven't got it, we DO> soon will have. About the only thing left is AI, I think. I forget who said it, but one scientist said (sometime around the turn of the 20th century I think) that he was going to get out of science because "everything has already been invented"!! He was wrong and, with respect, I think you are too. (Maybe we should start a thread about future trends in SF? But in a different message!) GM> Actually that's quite an interesting point, all the "old" SF has been GM> superceded, even Cyberpunk seems to have faIled to come true, what is GM> there left to come??? DO> Dunno; the 90s is not a decade that goes well with SF. It is looking DO> backwards rather than forwards. Hmm, maybe you're right. What new and exciting SF books have there been in the last five years or so? I'm finding it hard to think of any. Even Allen Steele's stuff is a modern interpretation of an old style genre. DO> BTW, I thought of another one that messes up your chronology - Brazil. I don't recall that one. Perhaps a few details...? DO> Better than all those 70s films, too. And Scanners, which I don't like DO> much. And where would The Lost Boys or The Witches of Eastwick fit? To be honest I don't think any of them fit comfortably into the SF genre, they are more of the Horror/ Fantasy style of stories. DO> (I can use them if you can use Alien and Batman). Possibly in the case of Batman, but I think Alien stands up well enough in the SF genre. DO> 12:01 was on TV a few weeks back - not a good film, but no special DO> effects there. I forget where I've seen or read it, but 12:01 (and Groundhog Day) were both very like a story I read from back in (at a guess) the '60s. Remakes don't exactly count. Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)