Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-08 17:30 · #73952 in PRATCHETT

In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by David Otton

Saturday April 06 1996 17:12, David Otton wrote to Mark Stevens:

 MS>> Dredd's great comic book material, but is it great movie material?
 MS>> Well, actually I think it is -- it's just that Danny Cannon tackled
 MS>> it the wrong way.

 DO> The film actually came out better than I expected - I thought that
 DO> the style (eg the Judge uniforms) wouldn't translate, but I was
 DO> wrong.

Visually it's perfect, but Cannon just comprompised the integrity of the comic strip and that's something I wasn't entirely happy with.

 DO>  I don't care about that - they can chew the comics into little bits
 DO> as far as I am concerned, as long as the result is a good film.

Well, I care. Imagine you'd created a comic series that had been running for well over 15 years and then someone came along to make a movie of it. How would you feel if all your characters were misrepresented, out-of-character and the 15 year continuity was completely thrown out of the window, and on top of all that, you weren't paid a single bean for the pleasure? If Danny Cannon had $80M to spend on a movie, then I'd rather he'd have gone for something else than making a mockery of a British institution.

Having said all that, 'Judge Dredd' is a pretty decent action movie and I enjoyed it, just so long as I pretended it had nothing to do with Dredd.

 MS>> As it is, the comic-book version of Dredd simply *isn't* something
 MS>> that would appeal to a mass audience.

 DO> I think they would have a hard time justifying a fascist hero in a
 DO> major film, but the humour would work well (Otto Sump, fatties,
 DO> simps).

It worked in 'Robocop'.


 .+'''+.    fido  ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27
 M A R K    email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk
 `+.,.+'    www   ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/

--- GEcho 1.00
 * Origin: Sitting by the Sacrifice Poles (2:254/151.27)