Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From David Otton · 1996-04-06 23:12 · #73834 in PRATCHETT

 -=> Quoting Mark Stevens to Ian Muirhead <=-

 Hi Mark,

 MS> Going back to my point about the viability of something (such as
 MS> Dredd) between two mediums. Dredd's great comic book material, but is
 MS> it great movie material? Well, actually I think it is -- it's just
 MS> that Danny Cannon tackled it the wrong way.
 The film actually came out better than I expected - I thought that the
 style (eg the Judge uniforms) wouldn't translate, but I was wrong.

 MS> He went for a version with mass-market appeal and kicked the comic
 MS> book continuity out of the window.
 I don't care about that - they can chew the comics into little bits as far
 as I am concerned, as long as the result is a good film.

 MS> As it is, the comic-book version of Dredd simply *isn't*
 MS> something that would appeal to a mass audience.
 I think they would have a hard time justifying a fascist hero in a major
 film, but the humour would work well (Otto Sump, fatties, simps).

 MS> So there we have a breach of the comic book's integrity, which didn't
 MS> need to happen. Okay, so with an $80M movie on his hands, Danny Cannon
 MS> *had* to rework the premise, but then if this was all for the benefit
 MS> of a mass-market audience, then perhaps Judge Dredd was the wrong film
 MS> to do it with.
 A decent plot would have saved that film. Its not like there weren't
 plenty to choose from... how about Judge Death, and Anderson and Dredd
 (joint leads) trying to track him down. That way they could have left the
 Dredd character as it was, and played him off against the lighter Anderson.

 And you wouldn't need any padding (like the Angel Gang).

 MS> In my opinion, Richard Stanley (Hardware, Dust Devil) would have been
 MS> the right director for that sort of approach to Judge Dredd.
 Well, he's already had practice at 2000AD conversions, hasn't he? ;)

 |)/\\/||)

... Perfect day for scrubbing the floor and other exciting things.
--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)