From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-07 09:05 · #73948 in PRATCHETT
In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by Graham Marsden
Tuesday April 02 1996 19:57, Graham Marsden wrote to David Otton: DO>> Doubt it - the FX are integral, not dropped in afterwards. DO>> Everybody starts with just a script, and that has to read well. GM> Hmm, call me a cynic, but I think it goes "look at all the fancy GM> special effects we can do. Let's get someone to write a story so we GM> can use them!" Hardly cynical because it's not even true. George Lucas originally just expected it to have average effects. After all, ILM were just a bunch of college drop-outs and people that no other fx group wanted. But they had the right attitude. Of course, *after* the event it's easy to say "bah, just a special effects showcase" but it was never written as one. The fact that the sfx turned out to be ground-breaking was a bonus. DO>> I'm curious to see the Dr Who (saw a trailer yesterday) GM> Was it any good? Did it make you think "wow, maybe this film is going GM> to be good" or was it just a lot of pretty FX? You seem to be quite obsessed with all this "pretty FX" business! Do you go and see a film and just sit there passing judgement on the FX or summat? DO>> and The Prisoner remakes. GM> Hmm, I've got *very* strong doubts about this one. I don't really GM> think that it should be remade, it could never capture the style of GM> the original. True -- they'd probably try and put too much pretty FX in. GM>> I would *love* to see what Johnny Mnemonic would have been like GM>> had they used Gibson's story and characterisations. There was hardly enough there for a full-length movie. DO>> Gibson was involved with that film from the beginning. GM> He was???? I am *extremely* surprised by that! Er, he wrote the actual script. GM> Ok, they had to change bits around to put it on the screen (and for GM> copyright reasons)... "Copyright reasons" has nothing to do with it. The publisher would have sold complete film rights -- they wouldn't say, "Well, we can't do this because it's already copyrighted in the book." If you own the movie rights, you can use whatever you want from the book. GM> but why on earth did he let them (or he put in himself) the GM> ridiculous and dire "my head's going to explode if I don't get rid of GM> this information" plot and the total wimp of a character who took GM> Molly's place? Because more people would flock to see that version of JM than a version more faithful to Gibbo's orginal story. Makes sense. .+'''+. fido ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27 M A R K email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk `+.,.+' www ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/ --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: Playing in the Snake Park (2:254/151.27)