Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-07 08:14 · #73944 in PRATCHETT

Thursday April 04 1996 12:47, Ian Muirhead wrote to Mark Stevens:

[Star Wars Killer]

 MS>> And I reckon the new trilogy will make SF even more popular and
 MS>> generate plenty more decent SF movies.

 IM> Indeed, I expect we will get another glut of them in a couple of
 IM> years...

It's certainly looking likely. With the likes of Kubrick and Spielberg also meant to be releasing sci-fi movies before the decade's out, you just know that all the major studios will be trying to do something to cash in.

 MS>> Take 'Dune' for instance, it was trying to *be* the novel on a
 MS>> cinema screen, and that just doesn't work.

 IM> True, but Dune wasn't /that/ bad a film, sure it was nothing like the
 IM> novel, and perhaps the only reason I liked it was that I had read the
 IM> Novel beforehand...

Yes, I think it's an okay film, but my point was that the film producers seem to think that all they've got to do to create a decent sci-fi film is just transfer a book directly to screen. It doesn't work like that though because they're two entirely different mediums. If 'Dune' was ever to work on the big screen, it needed to be a 180 minute movie where the visuals & sound are used to convey the themes of the novel. Instead Lynch just tried to basically create a copy of the book verbatim onto the big screen and the conversion simply doesn't work. The reason the likes of '2001' and 'Star Wars' have been successful is that they were always intended to be a film first and foremost. I mean, you don't go reading the SW novelisation after seeing the film and go, "Whoaar! This is a work of literary genius!"

 IM> Like everything else, from novels onwards, There is no such thing as
 IM> an original plot...

But there are original ways of tackling unoriginal plots.

 IM>>> And ever since, every SF film worth it's salt has had
 IM>>> morphing...

 MS>> 'Strange Days' didn't.

 IM> But most of the others in the years after T2 did...

It was probably 'The Abyss' that drew everyone's attention to morphing. A lot was made of ILM's water tentacle before the film was released. Of course, T2 provided the real showcase. In fact, if you want to go back further, the first instance of morphing (from ILM, naturally) is to be found in 'Willow'.

 MS>> I agree. I find it ridiculous that 'Star Wars' should be blamed
 MS>> for every cinematic failing, least of all those in the sci-fi
 MS>> genre.

 IM> And after all, there were dodgy SF films way before 'Star Wars'

Precisely.


 .+'''+.    fido  ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27
 M A R K    email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk
 `+.,.+'    www   ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/

--- GEcho 1.00
 * Origin: Sunbathing on the Exocet Deck (2:254/151.27)