Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From David Otton · 1996-04-07 03:52 · #73833 in PRATCHETT

 -=> Quoting Graham Marsden to David Otton <=-

 Hi Graham,

 GM> But is it? Ok, yes, you can put more detail into books because they
 GM> don't have to run for about 90 - 120 minutes, but surely there have
 GM> been plenty of films which have managed to include depth.
 I don't think there have. Using your bare bones trick, I can dismiss just
 about all of the SF films out there. Anyway, SF isn't really suited to film.

 DO> They show up all the time on TV - The Andromeda Strain springs to mind,
 GM> An example I've used myself a few times in this thread already!
 I've been thinking about this, and it isn't a very good film. It is very
 loose (you could cut 20mins out of it with no problems at all) and the plot
 is lifted straight from a 50s B movie (especially the ending). In general,
 it hasn't aged very well.

 I think that what you are doing here is saying "this is what I like, this
 is SF", and attacking the rest for not being what you like.

 GM> Phase IV, another good one.
 Has the same problems. I reckon it is because it is a product of the 70s,
 the decade that gave us all those horribly overblown rock supergroups,
 amongst other things that took themselves too seriously.

 DO> The Philidelphia Experiment (iffy),
 GM> *Well* iffy!!
 But a better film. Not great, but better. (Y'know the bit in ST:TNG when
 the woman gets melted through the deck? At least The Philedelphia Experiment
 had the guts to show them still moving ;)

 GM> I'm really not sure about Silent Running. Yes, it is an intelligent
 GM> and thought provoking film, but, IMO it just drags on too long.
 They all do. Nobody could accuse SW of taking itself too seriously.

 GM> Fair enough. I did, however, pick Star Wars because it was the first
 GM> example of this sort of film and represented a quantum leap in the way
 GM> that SF films were (and are) made and presented.
 So did 2001?

 [Quantum leap - just about the smallest leap that it is possible to make.
  Sorry, but it annoys me.]

 GM> Hmm, call me a cynic, but I think it goes "look at all the fancy
 GM> special effects we can do. Let's get someone to write a story so we can
 GM> use them!"
 Wotsisname intended to use traditional techniques to make Jurassic Park -
 they convinced him to try computer animation once the project was already
 up and running.

 DO>  I'm curious to see the Dr Who (saw a trailer yesterday)
 GM> Was it any good? Did it make you think "wow, maybe this film is going
 GM> to be good" or was it just a lot of pretty FX?
 I'm not even sure if it was for Dr Who, because I wasn't really watching.
 Man with floppy hair saying "I /am/ the Doctor" in what looked like an
 English country house with a stained glass window. I assumed it was just
 after a regeneration, and he was trying to convince an assistant.

 DO> and The Prisoner remakes.
 GM> Hmm, I've got *very* strong doubts about this one. I don't really
 GM> think that it should be remade, it could never capture the style of the
 GM> original.
 I don't think it should. That was of its time, and I would want something
 that is relevant today.

 DO> I may even go and see Steve Martin in Sgt Bilko.
 GM> I've seen a trailer and I think that Phil Silvers did it better (even
 GM> if he did play to his ego too much).
 Probably. I don't like Steve Martin that much.

 DO> The Addams Family was good stuff.
 GM> I'm really undecided about this one. I had the feeling that they were
 GM> trying just a bit *too* hard to make it work.
 "Are they made from real Girl Scouts?". Brilliant.

 DO> Where is the Blakes 7 remake, that's what I want to know.
 GM> Bring back Blakes 7!!!
 It's like ringing a bell for one of Pavlov's dogs...

 Look, you've been in denial long enough. They are /never/ going to show
 it again.

 GM> ...Johnny Mnemonic...
 DO> Gibson was involved with that film from the beginning.
 GM> He was???? I am *extremely* surprised by that! Ok, they had to change
 Search for wmgib10.zip on this board. S'about 11K. There is about 250 lines
 of disclaimer (Project Gutenburg etext) and then the interview starts.

 GM> bits around to put it on the screen (and for copyright reasons), but
 GM> why on earth did he let them (or he put in himself) the ridiculous and
 GM> dire "my head's going to explode if I don't get rid of this
 GM> information" plot
 Because he is ignorant of technology?

 GM> and the total wimp of a character who took Molly's place?
 No idea.

 DO>  It's understandable that the more gory end has gone down the
 DO> straight-to-video route - there are only so many ways you can cut up a
 DO> latex corpse.
 GM> I thought that was "The Roswell Incident"?! ;-)
 Hah. Yes, but that's in black and white - you can't see the blood.

 DO> The other, more thoughtful, thread in horror seems to have been killed
 DO> off because Kenneth Brannagh's Frankenstein remake bombed.
 GM> Now that is a shame. Before Hammer and co got their hands on it
 GM> Frankenstein was a good story.
 KB's was closer to the original than anything yet made... and suffers
 slightly from Dune-itis as a result, IMO. The recent Dracula was the
 same.

 GM> Unfortunately it then came "Monster with
 GM> bolts in its neck terrorises population" and it *totally* loses the
 GM> subtlety of the original.
 When read today, the original is not a very good book.

 DO> Do you really think that, say, The Andromeda Strain would have
 DO> outsold Jurassic Park if they had both been released on the same day?

 GM> That is an impossible question to answer.
 No, you're trying to avoid it.
 GM> There is something like 20
 GM> years between the two. One is a taut, thought provoking thriller, the
 GM> other had a massive advertising/ merchandising budget hyping it, there
 GM> is simply no way to compare them.
 Ok, you can remake it. Modern production values, pick your own stars, even
 FX if you want them, but you can't change the story or add CGI dinosaurs.
 Which makes more money?

 DO> Here's a thought: SF as a whole is in decline. The reason? The future
 DO> is already here, and there is nothing left to write about.
 GM> And I thought that *I* was a cynic!!!
 That isn't cynicism. Anyway, its true. If we haven't got it, we soon will
 have. About the only thing left is AI, I think.

 GM> Actually that's quite an interesting point, all the "old" SF (rockets,
 GM> rayguns, robots) has been more or less superceded, even Cyberpunk
 GM> (which was a product of the '80s) seems to have faIled to come true,
 GM> what is there left to come???
 Dunno; the 90s is not a decade that goes well with SF. It is looking
 backwards rather than forwards. Nobody wants to eat genetically modified
 tomatoes.

 GM> ... Plant flowers in your Window Box and watch them grow while you
 GM> wait...
 Nah, Windows is just an add-on shell for the DOS prompt. When I get the
 bugs ironed out of my new toy^H^H^Hcomputer I'm changing OSes.

 BTW, I thought of another one that messes up your chronology - Brazil.
 Better than all those 70s films, too. And Scanners, which I don't like
 much. And where would, say, The Lost Boys or The Witches of Eastwick fit?
 (I can use them if you can use Alien and Batman). 12:01 was on TV a few
 weeks back - not a good film, but no special effects there.

 |)/\\/||)

... Student of the Harry Tuttle school of Revolutionary Plumbing.
--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)