From Mark Stevens · 1996-04-08 17:08 · #73950 in PRATCHETT
In reply to Star Wars Killed the SF Film!! by David Otton
Saturday April 06 1996 21:52, David Otton wrote to Graham Marsden: GM>> but surely there have been plenty of films which have managed to GM>> include depth. DO> I don't think there have. Yes there have -- you just haven't been seeing them. Of course, I'm not just talking sci-fi here. DO> Anyway, SF isn't really suited to film. Yes it is. Look at '2001' and 'Blade Runner' and try and tell me otherwise. DO>> The Addams Family was good stuff. GM>> I'm really undecided about this one. I had the feeling that they GM>> were trying just a bit *too* hard to make it work. DO> "Are they made from real Girl Scouts?". Brilliant. I thought it was a pretty decent conversion too. The sequel was a bit, well... sequelish, but ten out of ten for the effort. You seen Barry Sonnenfeld's 'Get Shorty'? Brilliant film, and another good conversion (from Elmore Leonard's original novel). DO>> Do you really think that, say, The Andromeda Strain would have DO>> outsold Jurassic Park if they had both been released on the same DO>> day? GM>> That is an impossible question to answer. Not so much impossible, but unfair. Still, 'Jurassic Park' almost went up against a TAS-style movie. Ridley Scott was involved in 'Hot Zone' until the project folded. Anyway, given the current climate, then TAS wouldn't have faired too well against JP, but then what's the point of this comparison? They're two entirely different films for different audiences. DO> Ok, you can remake it. Modern production values, pick your own stars, DO> even FX if you want them, but you can't change the story or add CGI DO> dinosaurs. Which makes more money? Depends entirely on the marketing. With 'Jurassic Park' you've got Spielberg's name and ILM's dinosaurs to sell your movie. A remake of TAS would need to find similar devices. If it were me, I'd start putting teaser adverts in the cinema 6 months before release... you know those sorts of small teasers that tell you sod all and keep everyone guessing. For example, 'The Last Action Hero' -- audience sees some sort of explosion and gunfight through a tiny slot, Arnie walks up to the slot, puts his hand over it and says, "Not yet..." And that's it, that's all you're told. Or the 'Jurassic Park' teaser... just the JP logo accompanied by dinosaurs screeches and then a voice over saying, "Steven Spielberg will take you there..." Or the 'Back to the Future' teaser, with the DeLorean tearing along a desert road, skidding to a halt. Out steps Michael J Fox, looking at a watch, going, "I'm out of time...", gets back in the DeLorean and the car disappears in a trail of blazing fire. DO>> Here's a thought: SF as a whole is in decline. The reason? The DO>> future is already here, and there is nothing left to write about. GM>> And I thought that *I* was a cynic!!! DO> That isn't cynicism. Anyway, its true. If we haven't got it, we soon DO> will have. About the only thing left is AI, I think. Have you seen 'Strange Days'? Are you gonna see 'Twelve Monkeys'? 'Independence Day'? 'Crash'? The new 'Star Wars' trilogy? And for the record, 'AI' is now entitled 'Eyes Wide Shut' and it stars Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidman. It's scheduled for release in summer 1997, in which case it will be going head-to-head at the box office with Spielberg's 'The Lost World'. .+'''+. fido ¯ 2:254/151.27 & 2:254/255.27 M A R K email ¯ mark@sonance.demon.co.uk `+.,.+' www ¯ http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/sonance/ --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: Playing in the Snake Park (2:254/151.27)