Slimelite BBS

Good books

Back to PRATCHETT

From Eoghann Irving · 1996-03-31 20:39 · #73740 in PRATCHETT

On the 28 Mar 96 Robert Bull said to Lee Mann:

 RB> Crawford Killian "Eyas"  (a truly extraordinary novel that reads like 
 RB>   fantasy to start with, then changes into SF with a crash of gears)

     Crawford Killian.  I had a long conversation with him on usenet a couple of years ago.  He used to post to one of the writing newsgroups.  I always meant to look up some of his books.  I take it you think he's a good writer.  You don't know of any others he's written do you?


 RB>>> a fantasy called "Tigana" by  Guy Gavriel Kay, the source of a very
 RB>>> long enthusiastic thread here last  year.

 LM>> I don't usually like fantasy.  What's it like ?

 RB> Very un-fantasy-like; more like an adventure story.  The magic is a key
 RB> part but is not to the fore; in fact, it is rather too matter-of-fact
 RB> when  it does appear, IMHO.  The book is slow to start, you need to
 RB> stick with it  until the death watch for the old duke before it ignites,

     Another Tigana fan.  Great.  Its one of my favourites.  Have you read A Song For Arbonne?  Its almost as good I think.  Nothing works out quite the way you expect it too.  I can't get over how much better Guy's writing has got since The Fionavar(sp?) Tapestry.  That was an okay trilogy, but nothing spectacular.  Has he written anything else?

Eoghann

     ************************************************************
     ***   New SUPER SIZZLE.  It's SO good we ate the baby!   ***
     ************************************************************

--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: me (2:440/302.14)