From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-01 06:10 · #73746 in PRATCHETT
Hi Ian, GM> time to stir up a little controversy and get people talking...! IM> Ok, shoot... <<<*BANG*!!!>>> Oops, sorry, we've done that gag already, haven't we? [Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good] IM> Hmm, I don't know about that, when it was first released, it sure IM> got a lot of new fans interested in SF... But *what sort* of SF did they get interested in? The glitzy big box office spectacular SF with its big effects and small plots and two dimensional characters or the *real* SF with depth and content? GM> ever since Star Wars practically every SF film has been a big budget GM> special effects fest with lots of big sets, but with minimal attention GM> being paid to either plots or characterisations. IM> I think it's just the film industry in general, nearly all big films now IM> have big sets and budgets, not just SF, But there have been some very notable exceptions, haven't there? And a big budget and a big name star doesn't guarantee a good film, does it? (Remember Waterworld??) IM> I think the bigger problem is the inability of Hillywood to convert an IM> SF novel to the medium of the screen, just too much either gets changed IM> or left out, changing the entire character of the story... IMO it is the inability of Hollywood to *comprehend* the nature of SF and its desperate desire to pitch big budget films to the "mass market". Johnny Mnemonic went for that approach and failed spectacularly. GM> It is my contention that Hollywood has been so seduced by the "look GM> what we can do with the lights" mentality that they have failed to GM> apply the basic rules of what makes a good film to the SF genre IM> again, I think this is the film industry in general, look at the action IM> film genre, each film has bigger and better SFX, taking up so much IM> screen time, the plot somehow gets forgotten I think in Hollywood's mind, the Action film and the SF film are almost certainly inextricabaly linked. Look at Speed or True Lies, they could almost come under the SF genre, one just blends into the other. GM> In my opinion the SF film is a dying breed but that no one has yet GM> noticed because they are so dazzled by the pretty pictures that they GM> can't see that it is all superficiality and no depth. IM> If it is dying, it's looking pretty healthy for it. There never has been IM> a lot of depth in an SF film, nor in any normal length film, there IM> simply is not the run time to be able to explain everything... So how come someone like William Gibson can create a story like Johnny Mnemonic in just *twenty two pages*, yet Hollywood squanders the storyline in favour of masses of effects? Burning Chrome itself is only 24 pages long. *Why* can't that be explained in a movie that lasts for an hour and a half? Is it simply that Hollywood has lost the skill of actually *telling* a story? GM> There have been a *few* good films, eg Blade Runner and Alien, but GM> they cannot make up for the large amount of dross which is churned out GM> in the name of science fiction. IM> Did they not also have big plots, budgets and Star names? Blade Runner, yes, Alien? No. No big names, no *really* big sets, just some very good models. Most of the action takes place in small areas. IM> It all goes down to the quality of the scriptwriter and director, and IM> there is nothing which can affect that Unfortunately very true. For every Ridley Scott there are a dozen? hundred? wannabes who have no concept of what they are trying to do. GM> So, what do you think? Am I right? Am I out of my mind? Or am I GM> just being controversial?? ;-) IM> personally, I think you're just being controversial ;) Thankyou. (I'm glad you didn't pick the second option!!!) (Multiple exclamation marks...!) Cheers, Graham. --- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)