From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-01 06:49 · #73747 in PRATCHETT
Hi Mark,
MS> Hi Graham, nice argument! Makes a change from having someone quote
MS> your entire message and just go, "Yeah! Kewl!"
You liked it?
Yeah! Kewl!
(Sorry!)
MS> [TNG/Trek]
GM> How about Data (never uses contractions like I'm), except there are
GM> so many times when he does.
MS> This can be explained as part of Data's on-going quest to become more
MS> human. If not, then it's a case of suspending your disbelief just a
MS> little bit more.
"Explained"? "Excused", maybe...
MS> Given the amount of wordage Brent Spiner had to deliver, it's not
MS> unreasonable allow a few slip-ups.
IMO Brent Spiner was actually one of the best actors on the show. In the
context he was, IMO, better than Patrick Stewart. For instance in the
episode (I forget the title) where he is playing Data, Lore *and* Dr Soong,
it is quite amazing that the characterisations are *completely* different.
MS> Besides, was it ever said on-screen that Data never used contractions?
MS> Possibly, but I'm sure it was a case of him saying, "I do not use
MS> contractions" rather than "I never use contractions."
No, it is he "cannot use contractions" (I forget the exact quote).
The point being, however, that it has been a *major* plot point in at least
two episodes (as I'm sure I have mentioned elsewhere).
GM> Apart from some of the "filler" episodes of B5 (ie the non story-arc
GM> episodes) they are meant to be viewed as part of the whole.
MS> I still challenge your original assumption
^^^^^^^^^^
I think you mean "assertion".
MS> that B5 episodes can be enjoyed without knowing all the background. To
MS> a limited extent yes, but not half as much as a Trek episode can be
MS> enjoyed in isolation.
I think we're going to have to agree to disagree on this one then. The level
of enjoyment is something which can't be defined and it's pointless trying
to argue about it.
[Plots (Conspiracy)]
GM> which normally only deals with "stand alone" storylines? I think that
GM> is significant enough to be "glaring"
MS> In this case it's entirely subjective. Something like Data's use of
MS> contractions is more obvious, he does, so you can use your 'glaring'
MS> stuff there. But with Conspiracy it's a different kettle of fish. You're
MS> saying it's glaring because the potential to explore a particular aspect
MS> of an episode wasn't explored.
No, I'm saying it's "glaring" because it was effectively something that at
least two episodes were leading up to and then this massive loose end just
went flapping off into the void.
MS> I'm saying I'm glad they didn't, because the Conspiracy aliens are
MS> pretty daft and a throwback to the days of tacky TOS.
As someone said, "horses for courses". ;-)
[Lots more about Conspiracy cut]
[Data's had his chips]
<Grin!>
[But cut]
[Re: The Doctors true origins]
GM> Umm, he's a Timelord from Gallifrey... The Tom Baker incarnation dealt
GM> with a lot of stuff on Timelords and Gallifrey, I don't see your point
MS> you're obviously not up on your Doctor Who continuity. You've missed out
MS> on a whole stack of references that suggest it's not as simple as that.
MS> Off the top of my head...
[Cut]
Hmm, you obviously know more about it than me! I started gaving up on Dr Who
around the Peter Davidson, Colin Baker years (despite the pneumatic
attractions of Peri!). I came back to it a few times with Sylvester McCoy
(who, for my money, was actually pretty good and captured some of the old
William Hartnell spirit).
MS> Anyway, my point is that after 30 years the main character of a TV
MS> show still remains an enigma. A dangling, unresolved plot-thread
MS> which (according to you) is indicative of poorly-conceived sci-fi.
Umm, when did I ever say "poorly conceived"?
But, yes, I have to say that if I was a major Who fan I think I would have
found that becoming intensely annoying. At least with Babylon 5 I *know*
that JMS is going to do his damndest to resolve all the major plot threads
by the end of Season 5. With Dr Who, however, it just seems to be something
to keep stringing the fans along with no intent to ever actually *do*
something about it.
[More stuff cut]
MS> Fair enough. Although I still think your accusation that sci-fi
MS> fans are more intelligent non sci-fi fans is more relevant than...
MS> [Bollocks!]
The point with the "intelligence" part of the thread was that it seemed to
have reached a point where we were only going to be repeating old arguments
without taking it any further, so I cut it.
MS> What's more valid, someone just concluding with, "It's naff!" and
MS> nothing else, or someone concluding with, "It's bollocks!" and
MS> then going on to explain why (as I usually do)?
I merely contend that, of the two "It's naff" is, at least, less
confrontational and would, hopefully, result in meaningful debate instead of
a screenful of abuse.
I think this part of the discussion has also reached an end point, so I
think I'll leave it here.
Cheers,
Graham.
--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
* Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)