Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-01 05:45 · #73745 in PRATCHETT

Hi Eoghann,

[Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good]

EI> Well its certainly a controversial argument.

Hey, if it brings another lurker out of the woodwork and gets them to join
in it can't be too bad! ;-) Welcome!

 GM> since Star Wars came out practically every SF film has been a big
 GM> budget special effects fest with lots of big sets, but with minimal
 GM> attention being paid to either plots or characterisations.

EI> That sounds like most Hollywoord films to me. :)

Yes, ok, I fully agree, but we're talking specifically about SF here.

 GM> In my opinion the SF film is a dying breed but that no one has yet
 GM> noticed because they are so dazzled by the pretty pictures that they
 GM> can't see that it is all superficiality and no depth.

EI> Correction, even assuming you are correct, it only a certain type of SF
EI> film which is a dying breed.  You are making an assumption that only
EI> films of a certain quality can be called SF.

But how do you make the distinction? What would you put forward as a
definition of that "certain type" or "certain quality" which distinguishes
between the two?

 GM> There have been a *few* good films, eg Blade Runner and Alien, but they
 GM> cannot make up for the large amount of dross which is churned out in
 GM> the name of science fiction.

EI> The proportion of dross to classics in cinema in general has
EI> always been about 9 to 1.  That has nothing to do with Star Wars.
EI> If it wasn't for Star Wars there might have been no SF films made
EI> at all.  They are kind of expensive after all.

But there were SF films before Star Wars and they didn't rely on flashy
special effects to distract the viewer from noticing just how shallow and
superficial the plot and characters were, did they?

EI> This strikes me as a variation on the complaints many Doctor Who
EI> fans have made about the new film.  The idea being that simply
EI> because something spends money on SFX it is inevitably going to be
EI> shallow .  Although that is frequently true it is not always the
EI> case.  Lets be honest, films made on the cheap can be crap too.

But there have been *so many* films which seem to have spent all their money
on big name stars and expensive special effects, and when they have finished
with all they they spent the remaining $10.23 on having someone write a plot
and some characterisations.

There are also many SF films eg Tron, Terminator 2 etc which were written
*solely* as vehicles to hang special effects on.

EI> Besides, just look at some of the SF films that were made before
EI> Star Wars.  Are you honestly telling me that Plan 9 was good?

No, (although it was so bad it went beyond the "badness event horizon" and
out the other side!)

However there have been good SF films, 2001, This Island Earth, Forbidden
Planet, The Andromeda Strain etc, all of these were made before Star Wars
and they *did* have plots and characters with depth.

EI> All the above is just my humble opinion.

Of course, we'd expect nothing else. ;-)

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)