Slimelite BBS

Star Wars Killed the SF Film!!

Back to PRATCHETT

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-01 05:34 · #73744 in PRATCHETT

Hi Tony,

[Re: Star Wars has actually done more harm to the SF genre than good.

 GM> ever since Star Wars practically every SF film has been a big budget
 GM> special effects fest with lots of big sets, but with minimal
 GM> attention being paid to either plots or characterisations.

TP> The same could have been said for SF before, but without the budgets.
TP> For every "This Island Earth," there were ten "Attack of the 50 Foot
TP> Woman's"

Yes, ok, you've got a point. So did Star Wars merely update the genre so it
was doing the same old thing but with better effects?

TP> Films have always been derivative. SF or non-SF.

Possibly, it depends how fundamentally you look at them. I've been meaning
to get around to finding out what the "seven basic plots" (or however many
there are) actually are, but, yes, you can strip any plot down to some very
general fundamentals, however, there is something more than special effects
which turns any particular suspense film into, say, The Andromeda Strain.

 GM> It is my contention that Hollywood has been so seduced by the "look
 GM> what we can do with the lights" mentality that they have failed to
 GM> apply the basic rules of what makes a good film to the SF genre

TP> Not just Hollywood. We Brits have made some utter dross in the SF stakes

True, but there have been several notable films made over here which seem to
tip the balance in our favour.

 GM> IMO the SF film is a dying breed but that no one has yet noticed
 GM> because they are so dazzled by the pretty pictures that they can't see
 GM> that it is all superficiality and no depth.

TP> I don't want to labour the point, but that has always been the case. One
TP> of the earliest FX films produced was "The Sausage Machine." A man is
TP> fed into a machine, and he comes out as a string of sausages. What is
TP> that, if it isn't "all superficiality and no depth?"

I think you're stretching the point a bit, after all, another early film was
"Train arriving at a station"(!) but it was still popular because it was
something new.

There *have* been SF films which haven't relied on flashy special effects,
eg 2001: A Space Odyssey where the effects were so good that they could be
ignored (for the most part). With Star Wars, Termiator 2 etc, the effects
were almost *deliberately* emphasised to distract from the shallowness of
the plot and characters.

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)