Slimelite BBS

Re: Murdered Children

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Stuart Thompson · 1996-04-05 05:27 · #68595 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Murdered Children by Kieron Dunbar

It's Stu putting his two pennorth in about Murdered Children TO Kieron Dunbar.
Hi Kieron,
 KD>> One way of viewing it is that the penal system exists for the purpose
 KD>> of reforming those who enter it. If this reforming is to have any
 KD>> meaning, those who have been reformed by it would have to re-enter
 KD>> society. 
 ST>  But who is to say that they have reformed?

 KD> Prison psychiatrists. But as the risk of a convicted murderer
 KD> repeating the offence is fairly low (those who do it due to a

 Where do you get these stats from Kieron? I'm not doubting them I'd just like
 the source.

 KD> psychiatric disorder being convicted of manslaughter), it's often more
 KD> a question of what the life sentence review body thinks at the time.
 
 Don't you think that most of these Psychiatrists live in Ivory towers?
 I doubt that many would release convicted murderers if they thought there was
 a chance of them becoming neighbours.


 ST>  Look at the recent case of the man who was let out of a secure mental
 ST> hospital and then went home and murdered and dismembered his father.

 KD> The question is, what could have been done to detect the problem
 KD> beforehand. It doesn't mean that those in mental hospitals should never
 KD> be released, as there are many in them who are far less likely to kill
 KD> someone if released than are free. Also, you'd probably create problems
 KD> if you passed such a measure, as well as depressing staff morale.
 
 ST>  Why also should we allow people like Hindley, who knowingly killed a
 ST> number of children,the chance to walk free again. Did she ever offer her
 ST> victims that chance?

 KD> Because there is no precedent, or compelling reason, not to do so,


 Undoubtedly the victims families would strongly disagree with you Kieron.
 I'm afraid I will also have to agree to disagree.My personal involvement with
 possibly will never allow me to forgive.
 Ciao,
 Stu.

stu.thompson@zetnet.co.uk

... My hard disk is full! Maybe I'll try this message section thing.
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.20
 * Origin: Kneptune BBS (+44-161-777-8088) (2:250/109)