Slimelite BBS

Murdered Children

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Kieron Dunbar · 1996-04-07 16:58 · #68658 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Re: Murdered Children by Stuart Thompson

Once upon a time, Stuart Thompson wrote to me thus:

 KD>> Prison psychiatrists. But as the risk of a convicted murderer
 KD>> repeating the offence is fairly low (those who do it due to a
 ST>  Where do you get these stats from Kieron? I'm not doubting them I'd
 ST> just like the source.

I'm afraid I can't remember the source. However, killing your spouse, or one 
of your children, is unlikely to be something anyone is likely to repeat
(given that such children will no longer be children by the time the offender
gets out of prison).

 KD>> psychiatric disorder being convicted of manslaughter), it's often more
 KD>> a question of what the life sentence review body thinks at the time.
 ST>  Don't you think that most of these Psychiatrists live in Ivory towers?

I don't have the experience with prison psychiatrists to comment.

 ST>  I doubt that many would release convicted murderers if they thought
 ST> there was a chance of them becoming neighbours.

Why do you think this?

 ST>>  Why also should we allow people like Hindley, who knowingly killed a
 ST>> number of children,the chance to walk free again. Did she ever offer
 ST>> her victims that chance?
 KD>> Because there is no precedent, or compelling reason, not to do so,
 ST>  Undoubtedly the victims families would strongly disagree with you

Quite possible the same with many murderers (although by no means all, as
the
majority of murderers kill someone in their family).

 ST> Kieron. I'm afraid I will also have to agree to disagree.My personal
 ST> involvement with possibly will never allow me to forgive.

Maybe. EOT, then?

kwaheri, Kieron        Internet : ksches@rmplc.co.uk

--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: I don't claim to know everything. I don't have to. (2:442/103.11)