Slimelite BBS

Murdered Children

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Kieron Dunbar · 1996-04-02 06:43 · #68541 in AMIGA_NF

Once upon a time, Stuart Thompson wrote to me thus:

 KD>> a punishment, not a sanctuary. If let out, I would expect her to get
 KD>> whatever protection is appropriate for someone who had received
 KD>> numerous death threats.
 ST>  You mean like the protection she offered to the children that she
 ST> murdered?

Surprisingly enough, no.

 ST>>  Why should anybody who WILLINGLY kills another person be allowed
 ST>> freedom again?
 KD>> One way of viewing it is that the penal system exists for the purpose
 KD>> of reforming those who enter it. If this reforming is to have any
 KD>> meaning, those who have been reformed by it would have to re-enter
 KD>> society. 
 ST>  But who is to say that they have reformed?

Prison psychiatrists. But as the risk of a convicted murderer repeating the
offence is fairly low (those who do it due to a psychiatric disorder being
convicted of manslaughter), it's often more a question of what the life
sentence review body thinks at the time.

 ST>  Look at the recent case of the man who was let out of a secure mental
 ST> hospital and then went home and murdered and dismembered his father.

The question is, what could have been done to detect the problem beforehand.
It doesn't mean that those in mental hospitals should never be released, as
there are many in them who are far less likely to kill someone if released
than are free. Also, you'd probably create problems if you passed such a
measure, as well as depressing staff morale.

 ST>  Why also should we allow people like Hindley, who knowingly killed a
 ST> number of children,the chance to walk free again. Did she ever offer her
 ST> victims that chance?

Because there is no precedent, or compelling reason, not to do so, IMO.

kwaheri, Kieron        Internet : ksches@rmplc.co.uk

--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: A quoted tear-line is wasted bandwidth. (2:442/103.11)