Slimelite BBS

Green?

Back to INVENTIONS

From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-12 05:00 · #64143 in INVENTIONS

Hello Graham,

[Graham Marsden to Alex Macphee, Mar 31 '96]

AM> radio is extremely good at engaging the mind more deeply than TV.
GM> I agree that for simple discussions pictures are unnecessary.
AM> This doesn't inevitably follow. Discussions of scientific topics
AM> don't need to be "simple" merely because pictures are not present.
AM> Radio science programmes have dealt with some very demanding ideas
GM> But surely the relevant point is whether the average viewer/ listener can
GM> make sense of the topic, isn't it?

No, that is a different point.  My point here is that radio is
extremely good at engaging the mind more deeply than TV, as a matter
of practice. That is, that radio /at present/ deals highly effectively
with some fairly esoteric and abstruse topics in science.  TV, in
general, doesn't.  Indeed, it's arguable that the 'video-byte' nature
of TV causes it to concentrate its attention on material that can be
simplistically presented in picture form.  There is some extremely
facile and low-grade science programming on TV, pictures or no.

A visual presentation is extremely useful; I'm not arguing otherwise.

I am arguing against the suggestion that radio is suitable only for
"simple discussions" that don't need pictures, because it demonstrably
is far superior to that.  Visual presentation is not a necessity, and
that radio does rather well without it.  (It would hardly be radio if
it did it with it!)

-Alex

--- MsgPost 1.1
 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)