Slimelite BBS

Re: GREEN?

Back to INVENTIONS

From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-12 05:00 · #64144 in INVENTIONS

In reply to Green? by Alex Macphee

Hello Richard,

[Richard Walker to Alex Macphee, Apr 01 '96]

RW> [..], there is *no* way that the quality of LPs is better than tape!

The quality of LP has always, in general, been markedly and
demonstrably higher than the quality of 1-7/8 ips tape. Superior
bandwidth, superior dynamic range, superior frequency response.

RW> Sorry, but with the LPs you get all the hissing, clicks, pops
RW> and so on.

This was a problem with a mass-produced product, though one can only
astonished at the stylus/groove technology that produced a high-
quality S/N ratio from a system sensitive to movements measured in
fractions of a wavelength of light.

In general, there were two sources of cereal sound:  one due to
handling, and one a result of deterioration over time of some types of
vinyl mix, when some of the vinyl components crystallised out, causing
deformations of the groove, though this was a relatively infrequent
phenomenon.

As an LP collector since I was a teenager, and having a collection
approaching one and a half thousand titles in vinyl alone (and getting
on for the same in CD), I've always taken meticulous care in the way I
handle my vinyl disks (there are those in my family who consider it
close to a psychological disorder!), and as a result I have disks that
today are as pristine and acoustically excellent as they were the day
I bought them in the sixties.

Because of quality control problems, however, there were some
companies whose records I stopped buying, most notably EMI (shame,
superb catalog), and I subsequently stayed largely with DG and Decca,
with forays into smaller specialist labels.

Tapes were not superior to LPs, they merely suffered a different set
of problems, such as stretch, print-through, progressive de-
magnetisation...  I have a number of TCs (about a tenth the number of
LPs), and many of them display 'wooliness' of sound now.  Their
principal advantage was ease of handling and relative robustness. They
could also be played on inferior equipment without significant damage,
whereas irreversible degradation occurred on an LP played with a
stylus of more than 1mg tip mass and a playing weight of more than
3gm.

RW> About the only advantage that LPs/tapes have over CDs is the fact
RW> that they are analogue, rather than digital.

I have had the opportunity to put that to the test.  I've a number of
recordings on both CD and LP of the same performances (Bach Violin
Partitas, Arthur Grumiaux, LvB piano concertos, Stephen Kovacevich,
several mediaeval/renaissance music recordings from the Archiv label,
and several others), and the LP sound is still marginally superior.
My recording of Sibelius 4/Tapiola (Lorin Maazel), on Decca ffss,
still makes my hair stand on end, it's so magnificent, and Decca's
Jubilee issue of LvB 9 (Georg Solti), a quarter of a century later, is
still superb.

-Alex

--- MsgPost 1.1
 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)