From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-12 05:00 · #64142 in INVENTIONS
Hello Graham, [Graham Marsden to Alex Macphee, Mar 31 '96] AM> Actually, it's a very good analogy. You require electronic apparatus to AM> use each. You incur running costs to use each. What's the difference? GM> The difference is between a "one time startup cost" and "continuous GM> charges" (see below). Your argument was, I think, that people are excluded from some broadcast programmes on the basis of cost. Whether this is a one-off or a regular cost is both immaterial and logically inconsequential (they are both of the form a + kt for differing values of a and k). AM> Fidonet is free at the point of use only because somebody else - the AM> sysops - pick up the bill. In CompuServe, the users pick up the bill. GM> How much are Compuserve's online charges? My monthly connect time on CompuServe is five times that I spend on Fidonet, and my online charges on CIS are precisely those I pay on Fidonet. Zero. The truth remains that your Fidonet connect time is 'free' because somebody else, out of the goodness of his/her heart, is subsidising the cost of your hobby. GM> On Compuserve, however, I am being charged a GM> *fee* for the *usage* of the system which, I contend, is *not* GM> representative of the costs which my usage incurrs. So what? CIS is a commercial service. What do you expect from it? In terms of costings, the difference between it and Fidonet is only quantitative. Are you a CompuServe member? Do you think you should get it for free? What do you think are the costs your usage incurs? But the real issue here is about making a judgement on whether you want the service in question badly enough to fork out the costs of it over whatever period. GM> In the same way paying for a TV and the licence fee is not the same as GM> paying monthly charges for Sky, and then paying extra for the "premium GM> channels", and *then* paying *again* for "pay per view" events. I can't see how you are paying "again" for pay per view events if you haven't paid for them a first time. (Having said that, I personally wouldn't have pay-per-view TV, since I think I'm unlikely to consider it value for money!) AM> competition to BT does not come from tuppeny-ha'penny outfits, but AM> from huge multinational corporations with interests in cable, AM> entertainments and communications. GM> Yes, I'm perfectly aware of that, however, no matter what the size of your GM> business, if you are trying to get into an established market, you have to GM> be able to offer something that the other companies aren't offering. As I said, the competition compete on price. There are areas where BT is constrained by OfTel in service provision where BT had no existing market and the competition does. GM> The Cable companies had to pay for laying their cables and creating the GM> infrastructure for their systems, if they *also* had to compete against what GM> was effectively a monopoly supplier which could afford to take a short term GM> loss (by slashing its prices) to ensure long term success, then I don't GM> think that many would have taken it up. This is simply not true. Large multinationals do precisely that all the time: incurring a short-term loss to ensure long term success. Unless you imagine that large multinationals only ever tool up operations that recoup their costs on day one! You surely don't think that the companies laying cable only have cable interests? 'United Artists' is no one-horse outfit. AM> And the objection to the price-capping policies of OfTel toward BT AM> doesn't just come from BT, it is coming even more strongly from AM> the competition themselves! GM> How long have they been objecting to this? Years. GM> Is it only recently or have they GM> been complaining ever since the cable franchises were awarded? I would GM> suspect that it is the former because the playing field is now being GM> levelled out as the cable franchises become established. 'Level playing field' - wouldn't it be nice, eh? BT wouldn't have the uphill direction to travel in. Useful phrase, 'level playing field', the Red Queen would like that. AM> How few dollars do you think an outfit like AT&T have to splash around? GM> I'm sure they have lots of money, *however* that expenditure has to be GM> justified to the directors and the shareholders. When the cable franchises GM> were first on offer, who did BT have to justify their actions to? Its directors and shareholders, oddly enough. -Alex --- MsgPost 1.1 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)