From Timothy Edward Morgan · 1996-04-13 23:14 · #77524 in TREK.UK
In reply to Come on people....! by Graham Marsden
Graham Marsden looked down from his battlements at Timothy Edward Morgan's
barbarian horde, and shouted: "Come on people....!".
[No place for religion in RPG]
GM> Why on earth not? If you are playing a Fantasy game, especially one that
GM> is based on a pseudo-medieval society,
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
That's not a *real* medieval society, though, is it? All societies are created
by circumstance - you could just have easily ended up with a secular society in
Europe if things had been a little different. Why not an atheistic, low-tech,
society, with or without magic?
GM> Most RPG characters only have a religion because it is *required* of
GM> them, ie a Priest class or because it is advantageous to their character
Yes. So what about religions (or philosophical societies, to extend the point)
that don't give such game rewards? They might add to the richness of life in
the setting.
GM> However, seriously, I would find this as obnoxious and insulting as the
GM> "moral messages" that turn up in, for instance, Star Trek or various US
GM> cartoon series, little homilies ostensibly said by one character to
GM> another, but actually aimed at the viewer/ player.
I think I've mentioned this before, but I once met a man who uses RPGs to teach
kids about consequences. That's a different sort of moral education from the
trite statements in I've noticed in Star Trek: The Next Generation.
I really hadn't taken the "moralism of the day" syndrome into account before
asking the question, so [slap, slap] I've just slapped my own wrists for loose
thinking.
On the other hand, it does raise a question: do you find that some scenarios
are based on just the same sort of saccharine pseudo-ideology? (What comes to
my mind is the "villain of the week" syndrome, where PCs are pitted against
foul [seal hunters/nationalists/polluters/any other group it's faddish to hate]
because... "well, they're evil"!)
GM> IMO religion has as much place in RPGs as combat. You can run games
GM> without combat and, in the same way, you can run games without religion.
Yes, I think I'll agree with that.
--- Terminate 3.00/Pro
* Origin: The Ephemeral Library (2:2502/666.969)