Slimelite BBS

Come on people....!

Back to TREK.UK

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-07 01:29 · #77412 in TREK.UK

Hi Tim,

TEM> This should be controversial:

Really? ;-)

TEM> "Religion has no place whatsoever in RPG.  Discuss."

Why on earth not? If you are playing a Fantasy game, especially one that is
based on a pseudo-medieval society, gods and religions are, almost by
default, an integral part of the game.

TEM> Is this true?  Where do the limits lie for you?

Most RPGers I have met are basically pretty agnostic, they don't really give
a damn about the "real" religions, let alone the Fantasy ones.

Most RPG characters only have a religion because it is *required* of them,
ie a Priest class or because it is advantageous to their character (wow, if
I become a worshipper of Thor I get +1 on my warhammer). 

Personally I don't have any problem with religions in RPGs and, since they
add another element to the roleplaying equation I think that they are a
valid (although not *necessary*) part of the game.

TEM> Does anyone out there use RPGs to teach religious or moral values?
 
Hmm, I almost wish they did, that would be a good way of shutting the "moral
minority" up when they claim that RPGs teach Devil worship!

However, seriously, I would find this as obnoxious and insulting as the
"moral messages" that turn up in, for instance, Star Trek or various US
cartoon series, little homilies ostensibly said by one character to another,
but actually aimed at the viewer/ player.

There have been claims that D&D was deliberately constructed to teach
teamwork, fair play and cooperation (disguising this as "game balance"),
however I think that is a specious argument.

I feel that religion is as important as you wish to make it unless the game
dictates its necessity, for instance a game like Runequest wouldn't work
without religion since they form the game's basic premise.

Religions are also necessary if you are going to have religious character
classes, ie Priests, since it's a bit difficult to have a Priest who doesn't
have a religion!

IMO religion has as much place in RPGs as combat. You can run games without
combat and, in the same way, you can run games without religion.

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)