From Eoghann Irving · 1996-04-08 17:59 · #77435 in TREK.UK
In reply to Come on people....! by Graham Marsden
It was 06 Apr 96 when Graham Marsden turned to me and uttered these fatefull words:
GM> Hi Eoghann,
Hi Graham :)
GM> Firstly "RPGs are almost exclusively about fighting and conquering".
GM> Well, I have to admit that that is generally true, although I think it
GM> is a bit of a circular situation, ie the games are designed to be about
GM> fighting and conquering because that is what people do with them...
So someone has to break the circle. Of course its a bit of a risk since original RPGs tend not to sell very well. You can't really blame games companies for taking the easy option.
GM> Although, having said that, there are a few games which are exceptions
GM> to the rule, for instance Call of Cthulu which is (or should be) about
GM> using your brains rather than heavy weapons.
It is however set in the twenties which does cause problems for female characters if your going to be historically accurate. :(
GM> "There are so few women RPGers because RPGs are almost exclusively
GM> about fighting and conquering".
GM> That is a difficult question for a man to answer simply because we lack
GM> the right perspective. I think it would be best if any female members of
GM> this echo (Sue? Caroline?) were to put *their* viewpoints on this
GM> matter.
Thats pretty much why I asked it. A lot of noise is made about how women want different things from games, but no one actually seems to be able to say what it is that they want. I wonder sometimes if anyone actually asks them. :)
EI>> 2) If it is (I'm inclined to think it probably is). Can you think of
EI>> any games which are exceptions to this rule.
GM> Well, as mentioned above, Call of Cthulu. I believe that Ars Magica is
GM> also an exception, but I've never played it.
I haven't play Ars Magica either. Anyone out there care to comment?
GM> I think that the Amber RPG might also be an exception because it has
GM> quite a fundamentally different premise from most other games in that,
GM> in the Amber world system, the women are just as capable as the men if
GM> not more so.
I keep hearing about Amber. Whats it like?
GM> In Paranoia, too, it makes no difference whether the character is male
GM> or female (it doesn't matter, they'll all end up dead pretty quickly!),
GM> the way that the game is played is more important.
True. I think the comic RPGs tend to come off best when it comes to avoiding sexism. Which is rather sad when you think about it.
ET>> 3) Does it matter whether women are into roleplaying?
GM> The more women that get into roleplaying the more this image can be
GM> dispelled and the less RPGers will be seen as social misfits who
GM> haven't got a "life".
I don't really care how I'm perceived by strangers to be honest. I suppose I should want RPGing to have a good image so that more people would join in, but one of the things I like about it is that most morons think its for dweebs and so *don't* join in.
GM> Games like Call of Cthulu rely on intelligence and finding out
GM> information rather than simply killing things (generally because, in the
GM> game, you *can't* kill the monsters!!)
GM> Amber, also, relies on thinking and subterfuge, rather than the "ugh! I
GM> hit it with my sword" mentality.
GM> Paranoia, too, treats combat in a pretty trivial manner, it being much
GM> better to try to outwit your opponents than just blow them away.
All these examples still rely on a campaign structure though don't they. I'd be rather interested in a game where the PCs were minor nobles at court and had to scheme and manipulate their way to power. There might be a little fighting in that, but not much I suspect. Easier to persuade some mug to do the killing for you. :)
Have Fun,
Eoghann
************************************************************
*** New SUPER SIZZLE. It's SO good we ate the baby! ***
************************************************************
--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
* Origin: A deeply distrubed mind (2:440/302.14@FidoNet)