Slimelite BBS

Come on people....!

Back to TREK.UK

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-07 01:54 · #77414 in TREK.UK

Hi Eoghann,

EI> one of the reasons there are so few women RPGers is that RPGs are almost
ET> exclusively about fighting, and conquering.

EI> This raises a few questions:-

EI> 1) Is the statement true?

Hmm, there's actually two statements there, so let's take them in reverse
order and see what comes out...

Firstly "RPGs are almost exclusively about fighting and conquering".

Well, I have to admit that that is generally true, although I think it is a
bit of a circular situation, ie the games are designed to be about fighting
and conquering because that is what people do with them...

Although, having said that, there are a few games which are exceptions to
the rule, for instance Call of Cthulu which is (or should be) about using
your brains rather than heavy weapons.

As to whether this is the sort of thing that women are looking for from
RPGs, then we come to the second statement viz:

"There are so few women RPGers because RPGs are almost exclusively about
fighting and conquering".

That is a difficult question for a man to answer simply because we lack the
right perspective. I think it would be best if any female members of this
echo (Sue? Caroline?) were to put *their* viewpoints on this matter.

EI> 2) If it is (I'm inclined to think it probably is). Can you think
EI> of any games which are exceptions to this rule.

Well, as mentioned above, Call of Cthulu. I believe that Ars Magica is also
an exception, but I've never played it.

I think that the Amber RPG might also be an exception because it has quite a
fundamentally different premise from most other games in that, in the Amber
world system, the women are just as capable as the men if not more so.

In Paranoia, too, it makes no difference whether the character is male or
female (it doesn't matter, they'll all end up dead pretty quickly!), the way
that the game is played is more important.

ET> 3) Does it matter whether women are into roleplaying?

Of course it does! RPGing is still very much seen as the preserve of the
"spotty faced Kevin" which is, of course, not the true situation, but it is
how it is perceived.

The more women that get into roleplaying the more this image can be
dispelled and the less RPGers will be seen as social misfits who haven't got
a "life".

ET> 4) If a roleplaying game wasn't based on conquest etc, what is the
EI> alternative.  The first time I read the editorial I couldn't think
EI> of any alternatives, but now I've had time to digest it I'm begining
EI> to see a few possibilities.

Games like Call of Cthulu rely on intelligence and finding out information
rather than simply killing things (generally because, in the game, you
*can't* kill the monsters!!)

Amber, also, relies on thinking and subterfuge, rather than the "ugh! I hit
it with my sword" mentality.

Paranoia, too, treats combat in a pretty trivial manner, it being much
better to try to outwit your opponents than just blow them away.

EI> Lets here some comments on the above.

Ok, how's that?

EI> Alternatively post your own topic, then you won't have to bother
EI> with mine. :)

I've already done that a while back. It's someone else's turn!!

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)