From Paul West · 1996-04-05 02:26 · #77354 in PENPAL
In reply to Poem. by Manny Neira
On 31-Mar-96, something quite extraordinary happened. You revealed to Paul West that it was to do with "Poem."! Jolly good show Manny! Forgive me innocence, but I cannot tell wether you are male or female, as I have not heard of your name before. [Needing to know before being taught] MN> The paradox runs something like this: when I encounter a new piece of MN> knowledge, how do I recognise it as such? How do I know it is true? If MN> I can recognise it as true, I must have known it already: because I MN> can only verify it by comparing it with what I already know. Agreed. True, therefore, means for you to be at-one with something, for the thing perceived and the perceiver to be in a kind of unison. This all stems from infinity, the ultimate intangible truth. MN> I have encountered two philosophers who took this problem seriously. MN> The first was an ancient Greek, who put forward the theory that before MN> our current lives we had a kind of pre-existence, in which we *really* MN> learnt everything, and that what passes for learning in this life is MN> really a matter of gradually remembering things we already knew: I agree on the basis of this argument. Indeed, before we embarked on what we call civilisation we have all there is to know - unity with the absolute, unity with nature. Then we `fell' and are now fallen. As such now anything we do is a struggle to climb back up again, so essentially to go backwards to what we truly were and are. After a certain point you can forget about it being a linear effort and so the paradox is broken somewhat, but until then we've still got the problem of the student needing to already know what he is taught. MN> The second solution was offered by Spinoza, who thought that each MN> piece of learning was a kind of miracle: whereby new information was MN> added to our minds by God. Spinoza's idea of God was a little off the MN> beaten Judeo-Christian track, though. God is what he is, and becaus he is infinite there is no `other'. Thus he ONLY is what he is. He hands this on to us. We are free to be what we are. In our fallen state we are on a road back to the creator. Thus we do what is tangibly called `expansion', which is actually the reverse direction. In this journey we `grow', and are free to be what we grow into. We are allowed to grow by way of learning how to be other than our original design suggests, but even then we are still only allowed to be what we are. You can't do something if you don't know how. I don't really think its a case of `new' information, because all things are within the infinite, so are just sort of variations on a theme. Variations on yourself is what allows you to apparently grow. MN> Personally, I feel that the answer depends on the kind of information MN> being offered. Some new knowledge is accepted merely on authority: on MN> the grounds that because the person passing it on is very learned or MN> experienced, he ought to know. Indeed, authority is a good place to start. Especially if that authority is God. But any authority less than God is unwhole, hense their knowledge and information is not wholly the truth, uless you're talking relative truth. MN> Indeed, this is probably the single MN> most important source of factual information. All of us know New York MN> exists, though very few of us have been there. Other new knowledge can MN> be verified by experimentation (as in science) or proven to be MN> necessarily implied by existing knowledge (as in mathematics). But this is all tangible truth though. The whole truth is not tangible. MN> But I think the kind of knowledge passed on by much good poetry (and MN> some prose) is not new at all. Its importance lies not so much in MN> telling us something new, but making conscious something that we MN> suddenly realise has always been a subconscious part of our emotional MN> and intellectual outlook. It raises consciousness, rather than MN> educating. Understood. If you like, in the beginning we were a little man and we have tonnes of baggage piled on our backs. Learning is seen as becoming at-one with the baggage, and reality helps out in this by presenting the baggage to us externally. Thus we learn from experience. We also learn from knowledge. Over time we shed more and more of this baggage revealing more and more of the truth. However, the true truth is not tangible, so once you've shed all this baggage you have to make sure you're not going to pick up any more - which requires you to let go of all you've learnt. Truly, if you are attatched to some old baggage you supposedly discared, you're no better off. If you are to learn about the baggage, to shed it, you must then let it go. Unfortuantely we use past learning as a resource and so really we are not learning anything. We are not doing anything other than formulating ties between ourselves and our burdens, our life. To reach the clean state we'd have to not only let go of the baggage but also let go of the so-valued thing we call `intelligence', for really it is a disease of deception. MN> I took this echo because I am working on an essentially philosophical MN> work, provisionally entitled "In Defence of Reason". I am thinking about starting on a `philosophical work', but in a totally opposite paradigm against reason. As I said above, you can learn lots of things about the baggage you are carrying, but in doing so you only make more baggage in the form of knowledge and associations and so on. These troubled times in the world today demonstrate this clearly. If we are not to be `saved' by some second-coming or whatever, the future is not good. MN> It seeks to MN> convince the intelligent lay reader that many individual and social MN> problems arise from irrationality, and that education in the means and MN> aims of logical thought would better equip us to deal with the world MN> and achieve our aims. True, but we are not really here to deal with the world. We are here to get to the point where we don't need to be here. There is no other difference achievable. The only thing about us being in the physical world is that we ARE HERE. So the only true achievement you can have is to get to a point where you no longer need be here. And death isn't the answer either because I also believe in reincarnation/transmigration. There is nothing you can do in the physical world which is `true'. The ONLY true thing you can do is realise what the world is and to then transcend it, moving into the next level. Any other persuit just takes you round in circles. The main problem is that for people keen on the physical world they have developed this `science' and this `logic' based on tangible truth. This is all very well and good, except that tangible truth has a limit. Thus there is no conceptualisation of `beyond' in that limit. Thus nobody can find proof of an afterlife, nobody can prove God. But at the same time they cannot disprove it. I seek, in my proposed book, to flip to an intangible-proof paradigm in which infinity is the truth, and to then put into perspective all the tangible perceptions of life we have. IOW not challenging science, but going beyond it to truly put it in its place. I have, however, started this work a few times. The problem with infinity is that it's hard to know where to start or where to stop, thus presenting it in a book is somewhat taxing, even contradictory to the concept of language. That I am also seeking to find God also doesn't help in that way, other than to supply me with more insights. Someone once said that to express God in what you do is the highest form of perfection, be it through art, writing, whatever. I am trying to do that, and the level of perfection certainly has its price. MN> It begins with a discussion of the rational process itself, MN> contrasting it with the way we commonly think, How we commonly think, or what we commonly think OF? MN> and moves on to discuss MN> the likely result of applying rational thought to issues such as MN> nationality, the family, and individual psychology. As soon as you get into the mind, rationality makes mistakes because the mind isn't tangible. MN> The philosophical MN> subject matter, leaving aside the quality of the writing, make MN> eventual publication extremely unlikely, For me it's trying to talk about infinity, having to leave aside much of the tangibility of language, which proves to be a constant problem. MN> but if anyone is interested I MN> should like an opportunity to occassionally post parts of it in the MN> echo for comment. Well I certainly wouldn't mind to hear it, but of course it's up to others also, and I don't know if it would be on-topic or whatever. Unless you only want discussion about the writing itself. Regards, Paul. Fidonet 2:251/31.8 PsychoNet 1080:108/0.4 IncarNet 153:250/8.4 --- * Origin: Delirious BBS, Hants. (2:251/31.8)