From Manny Neira · 1996-03-31 20:41 · #77350 in PENPAL
Hello Paul! PW> I have a question. How is it possible that what you write about PW> is understood by others, even if others might understand more PW> about the subject than you? What I mean is, say I knew more about PW> `the after life' than another person, is it actually possible for PW> me to tell them about it in a way they will understand, PW> considering they don't already know about it to that extent? This is the old philosophical paradox of learning, though perhaps newly applied to aesthetic and emotional issues. The paradox runs something like this: when I encounter a new piece of knowledge, how do I recognise it as such? How do I know it is true? If I can recognise it as true, I must have known it already: because I can only verify it by comparing it with what I already know. I have encountered two philosophers who took this problem seriously. The first was an ancient Greek, who put forward the theory that before our current lives we had a kind of pre-existence, in which we *really* learnt everything, and that what passes for learning in this life is really a matter of gradually remembering things we already knew: prompted by the comments of others and by experience. I'm damned if I can remember his name, and after searching through a pile of books cannot find my original source. The second solution was offered by Spinoza, who thought that each piece of learning was a kind of miracle: whereby new information was added to our minds by God. Spinoza's idea of God was a little off the beaten Judeo-Christian track, though. Personally, I feel that the answer depends on the kind of information being offered. Some new knowledge is accepted merely on authority: on the grounds that because the person passing it on is very learned or experienced, he ought to know. Indeed, this is probably the single most important source of factual information. All of us know New York exists, though very few of us have been there. Other new knowledge can be verified by experimentation (as in science) or proven to be necessarily implied by existing knowledge (as in mathematics). But I think the kind of knowledge passed on by much good poetry (and some prose) is not new at all. Its importance lies not so much in telling us something new, but making conscious something that we suddenly realise has always been a subconscious part of our emotional and intellectual outlook. It raises consciousness, rather than educating. I took this echo because I am working on an essentially philosophical work, provisionally entitled "In Defence of Reason". It seeks to convince the intelligent lay reader that many individual and social problems arise from irrationality, and that education in the means and aims of logical thought would better equip us to deal with the world and achieve our aims. It begins with a discussion of the rational process itself, contrasting it with the way we commonly think, and moves on to discuss the likely result of applying rational thought to issues such as nationality, the family, and individual psychology. The philosophical subject matter, leaving aside the quality of the writing, make eventual publication extremely unlikely, but if anyone is interested I should like an opportunity to occassionally post parts of it in the echo for comment. (\/)anny --- GoldED 2.42.G0615+ * Origin: Point Manny, U.K. (2:440/308.5)