Slimelite BBS

Re: Jack in a box is dead

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Leslie Rhorer · 1996-04-03 06:10 · #76636 in AMIGA_VIDEO

 PR> Where'd all this stuff come from?  That message (my reply to Donald
 PR> Hines) must have been three weeks or a month old!

        I am usually way behind, until I can get an hour or two to catch up.

 PR> mind if I ignore all this--I really don't want to resurrect this
 PR> thread.  I think it's been beat to death.

        Except that you still don't seem to understand it.

 PR> Let's just agree to disagree.  To you "Mass is energy, and energy mass.
 PR> That is all ye know and all ye need to know."

        No, it is not all one needs to know, nor is it all I know, nor is the statement correct.  Mass is *REST* energy.  Energy that is not rest energy is not mass, and vice versa.  Energy tied to a rest frame is what produces mass.  Nothing else produces mass.  No energy tied to a rest frame can fail to be measured as mass.  It is what mass *IS*, and any change in rest energy *IS* a change in mass, just as any change in the volume of an incompressible fluid *IS* a change in the number of molecules, and any change in the number of grains of sand in a sand dune *IS* a change in its weight.

 PR> But I am a Chemist by
 PR> training.  And Chemistry is nothing if not fascination with the myriad
 PR> other manifestations of matter.

        That's fine, but it doesn't make it proper for you to ignore the relativistic aspects of CHEMISTRY.

 PR> Just call me an old fogey classicist.

        I'm afraid what I have to call you is just plain wrong.


 PR> LR|o|        Particles running around a cyclotron have the 
 PR> same mass as tyhe
 PR>   |o|same particles at rest.

 PR> I never did the experiments myself, mind you, but I explicitly remember
 PR> being taught that relativistic effects were positively shown in various
 PR> cyclotron experiments.

        Relativistic effects positively *ABOUND* in cyclotron experiments (and I worked on a cyclotron project for over two years).  Indeed, the cyclotron itself would not work if not for Relativity.  But mass is Lorentz invariant, and no changes in mass would be observed even for particles traveling at .9999999999999999999999999999999999c

 PR> Radioactive ions accelerated to very large
 PR> fractions of "c" demonstrated time dilation and slowed their half-life
 PR> decay rates--as seen from our non-accelerated frame of reference.

        I don't know of any ions which have ever been accelerated to anything approaching c.  This doesn't mean it hasn't been done, but I can't imagine how.  Ions are far too massive.  However, muons are continuously being produced by cosmic radiation in the upper atmosphere, and one of the first verifications of SR was the fact they managed to reach us here on the ground, because of time dilation.  But time dilation is a proper effect of SR and GR.  Mass dilation is not.  Oh, and the muons decay is not decreased due to any acceleration effects.  Their frame of reference is no more accelerated than ours.  Their time-clock appears slowed to us - just as our time clock appears slowed to them.

 PR> also from calculations from cloud chamber collisions they were able to
 PR> calculate the mass also increased as predicted by Einstein.

        Einstein never predicted this, and as the FAQ I posted just yesterday showed, Einstein was quite clear that attempting to suggest a "relativistic mass" is an extremely poor idea.

 PR> Can't teach
 PR> old dogs, so I'll keep believing what I was taught.

        That's nonsense.  In the first place, it's anti-scientific.  Knowledge keeps changing and growing, and what was once thought correct may one day become obsolete.  This is the very nature and lifeblood of science.  In this case, however, the notions you were taught never were thought to be correct by the scientific community in the first place, including emphatically the father of Relativity.

                                                        Les

e-mail: lrhorer@fibrcom.com

--- EZPoint V2.2
 * Origin:   GUI?  Ptui!!!  ---  Last Chance Pt 4 (1:387/800.4)