Slimelite BBS

Re: Benefits:drinking/smo

Back to AMIGA_VIDEO

From Leslie Rhorer · 1996-04-03 06:03 · #76635 in AMIGA_VIDEO

 PR> LR|o|        I don't think so.  Tomatoes are, but no 
 PR> nightshade, to my limited
 PR>   |o|knowledge, is a tuber.  That potato skins might 
 PR> contain an alkaloid is
 PR>   |o|another matter - I have no idea.

 PR> Potato skins, especially green ones, contain solanine.  Trust me!  It's

        I never said they didn't.

 PR> LR|o|        Tobacco also makes an extremely effective 
 PR> insecticide, but this
 PR>   |o|doesn't mean it is a nightshade.  Ditto curare, toadstools, and about
 PR>   |o|100,000 other deadly plants.  Nightshades are among 
 PR> the deadliest, though.

 PR> I didn't say they were.

        I know, but you offered as evidence potatoes are nightshades teh fact they contain poison.  This does not constitute evidence.

 PR> Only that potatoes are.  Whether the nicotiana
 PR> or fungi such as Amanitre muscaria or thousands of other plants are also
 PR> deadly is irrelevant to whether potatoes are nightshades.

        And whether potatoes are deadly is similarly irrelevant to whether potatoes are nightshades.

 PR> solanine from potato skins is not.  You're right, your knowledge is
 PR> limited.

        I said so.

 PR> Oh hell!  You won't believe me.

        Sure I would, if you back up your statements with evidence, especially since I had no particular evidence of my own.

 PR> Maybe you'll believe Grolier's.

        In this instance, yes.  It is not really a scientific reference, however, and a biology field guide would have more credibility.

                                                        Les

e-mail: lrhorer@fibrcom.com

--- EZPoint V2.2
 * Origin:   GUI?  Ptui!!!  ---  Last Chance Pt 4 (1:387/800.4)