From Chris Lawrence · 1996-04-01 11:40 · #76555 in AMIGA_VIDEO
Hi Gary, Gary Depietro wrote in a message to Ken Stuckas: GD> Data from Newman follows. GD> Subject: PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF ONE NEWMAN MOTOR GD> PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF ONE NEWMAN MOTOR -- Part A [40 screens of data cut] Phew!! If you do that again, you might want to try splitting it up into messages each of about 6 or 7 screens (approx. 8k). This is because some Fido systems simply chop off anything after that amount (although most would automatically cut it up anyway). Well this is the first 'real' post you've submitted, as far as I can see. I've looked at it and have some comments. First, there is a terrible mix of units. Metres and Watts here, pounds and feet there. This only leads to confusion as constant conversion is required. This can be used as a 'smokescreen' to confuse a reader so that they eventually say, "Oh, sod it - I'll just accept the figures". Secondly, I'm getting a really awful feeling that Newman is seeing an effect which is no secret and has been known about for donkey's years. When you have a coil and you change the voltage across it, things happen. ** How much happens depends on how quickly the change takes place **. By "change the voltage", I could mean that a waveform (such as one where the voltage varies sinusoidally with time) is applied or I could mean a TRANSIENT voltage, which is where a voltage change happens momentarily. This is the case here with Newman's device. When a voltage from a battery is applied to the coil, there is a change in voltage across the coil from nothing to whatever the voltage of the battery is. This causes a change in current through the device from nothing to some final value. The current change doesn't happen at the same time as the voltage change - there is a slight delay. It is like pushing something through treacle - you can push now (the voltage change) and see movement starting a second later (the current starting flowing). This current change causes a change in the magnetic flux within the coil from nothing to whatever the final strength is. The changing magnetic flux induces a voltage (or EMF) within the coil (you need to understand Faraday's experiments, Gary) and this voltage is called the BACK EMF because it acts to produce a current which opposes the applied voltage (battery) change, just like pushing the thing through the treacle, causes the treacle to 'push back' against you as you gather speed. Since the current changes quickly, the back EMF is very large compared with the battery voltage. Now, if the battery voltage is removed again (by simply flicking a switch), again there is a transient voltage across the coil. As the voltage drops very quickly (again from something to nothing all of a sudden), the current changes too (again, not exactly at the same time). The changing current causes a change in the magnetic flux within the coil and this causes another back EMF which opposes the change in voltage (the back EMF now 'tries' to keep the diminishing current going). This is like suddenly stopping pushing this thing through the treacle, but it carries on going because you got it up to speed and kept it there for a while. This well understood process is called SELF-INDUCTION, because it is changing flux within the same coil which produces the back EMF. If the current is increasing, the back EMF opposes the increase. If the current is decreasing, the back EMF opposes the decrease. Try this - get hold of a coil of wire, or wind one up yourself. Hold one end of the coil on one end of a 1.5 volt battery, and touch the other wire on and off the other end of the battery. Each time you remove the wire, you will see a little spark, as the back EMF rises to massive proportions, enough to break down a small amount of air - much more than the 1.5 volts available from the battery. Now power, which is the rate at which work is done can be derived from the voltage times the current. But you have to take the values AT THE SAME TIME. You can't just take the 'best' voltage and current which you saw and multiply them together. If I applied a sinusoidal voltage to the coil, I'd see a sinusoidal current through it. But, unlike with a resistor, the peaks of the waveform wouldn't line up in time, because of the delay I mentioned. You cannot take the RMS (as an AC meter would measure) voltage and RMS current and multiply them together to get a power reading. The voltage and current are said to be "out of phase". You can only do that when the current and voltage are in phase. If you actually DO go ahead and do it anyway, you will get some strange readings. You will get varying power readings depending on the coil. You can actually get a large reading which appears to show that there is much more power than the voltage and current can account for, just like the voltage for the spark in the above experiment appears to come from nowhere. Newman is attributing this 'extra power' to the mechanics of his machine. In fact, it is easily explainable, as you can now see, Gary. The answer is that there isn't really any extra power at all - he is measuring things incorrectly. If we measure things incorrectly, we can all 'prove' anything we want to, can't we? I set this puzzle of where the extra voltage, as read on a meter, comes from, when applying a certain frequency to a certain coil, to some students a couple of years ago. In the end, over half worked through it and showed that it was perfectly normal to have all that extra voltage. It was just that when multiplied by the current and taking into acount the phase difference, the power output was slightly less than the power input, as would be expected. GD> VII. Unusual (Non Conventional) Behavior GD> As seen above, a number of properties of the Newman Motor follow GD> ... GD> My opinion is that an excess charge is left in the coil when the GD> input voltage is cut off. At this point, a spark appears and a GD> huge induced e.m.f. is created in the coil. This e.m.f. SHOULD GD> ... Tut tut tut! And unless I missed it, I didn't see any references to atomic processes within copper which I thought was meant to be the amazing theory behind all this? Regards, Chris - in Liverpool, UK FidoNet: 2:250/163.7 - Internet: chrisl@wsbbs.sentinel.co.uk --- timEd/386 1.10+ * Origin: Chris' point off -=Worcester Sauce=- Manchester, UK (2:250/163.7)