From Volker Multhopp · 1996-03-28 21:34 · #76522 in AMIGA_VIDEO
[Quotes are from a msg 03-28-96, Walt Stone to Volker Multhopp.]
Greetings Walt,
WS> The biggest beef the professor has now is the fact that some
WS> of the major "impactors" have now switched; instead of
WS> having a giant impact that causes massive cooling, they have
WS> decided that it must have triggered greenhouse warming.
It can be infuriating if your "opponents" can freely go off
180 deg in the other direction.
WS> picture I get on all of this. The impact most likely
WS> happened and might very well have provided some or most of
WS> the evidence that exists in the K/T sites around the world.
We make progress!
WS> Well, actually, if a good portion of the asteroid broke up
WS> and burned in the upper atmosphere, the dust could have been
WS> up there to start with, without any need to bring the plume
WS> of stuff up from the surface to around 15-20 miles or so,
WS> which would put it out of the reach of the adiabatic
WS> processes for more than one or two circulations around the
WS> globe. It is real hard to get stuff up that high from the
WS> lower atmosphere, even with a directed blast. But if the
WS> stuff was indeed there from the impact with the upper
WS> atmosphere, especially with a broken up asteroid, there
WS> should be some sort of ash evidence or evidence of
WS> alteration at some of the sites.
Oops! I think you're showing here a very substantial
underappreciation of the magnitude of the event. I think
"Katie" is often described as a 10km asteroid. Remember that
the typical *shooting star* you may see on a clear night is only
the size of a grain of sand. Even a 1kg meteor is substantial
enough to reach the ground. Consider that an asteroid will hit
the earth at maybe 40 km/s-- that means every gram of Katie
packs 80 000J of kinetic energy, enough, if it were water, to
raise its temperture about 19 000C!
The atmosphere would not measurably slow Katie down--
indeed, it will go through most of the atmosphere (masswise) in
a fraction of a second. Otoh, it has drilled a vacuum cylinder
through the atmosphere that will take about 15 s to collapse!
At first contact with the ground, the top is still as high as
Everest. As ground and Katie connect, they are being compressed
to unsustainable superdensities, temporarily taking up some of
the kinetic energy, and only some the kE is racing off as shock
waves. In 1/10 s Katie has sunk to its equator. A huge wave of
earth is heaving up around the perimeter and will race away 10s
of km, destroying everything in its path without pause until it
at last becomes frozen as a perfect mountain ring. In 1/5 s the
shock and pressure has totally shattered Katie, it is glowing
white hot, and it is beginning to spread horizontally even while
pushing into the earth. Tremendous amounts of material is
ejected away (squirted out) from the edge of the impact.
Finally the point is reached where the supercompression
overcomes the kE. The superhot mass explodes, and is propelled
back out into space in an enormous fireball. The earth
overrebounds leaving a red hot mountain of earth (not Katie)
standing at the impact point.
Now we have at least 3 distinct sources for fallout. The
ejected material-- I suspect a lot of that will be larger
material-- see the rays on the moon. Then there will be the
fireball in space stuff-- it will land on the upper atmosphere,
but I am not certain it will settle "uniformly"-- it may create
upper atmosphere clouds which might have their own dynamics.
Then there would be "locally" produced dust, it would be lofted
by residual heat from the impact for days, and be carried away
by the prevailing winds.
--Volker
* SLMR 2.1a *
--- Maximus/2 3.01
* Origin: Nerve Center - Source of the SPINAL_INJURY echo! (1:261/1000)