From Volker Multhopp · 1996-03-28 16:17 · #76521 in AMIGA_VIDEO
[Quotes are from a msg 03-27-96, Vince Barmann to Volker Multhopp.]
Greetings Vince,
VM>> Now try to contratest your own position. Why do insects
VM>> have 6 legs? For speed (dubious on its face since quad is
VM>> probably always faster)?
VB> It's the brain limitation,
Yes, that's my point.
VB>and the fact that they have so little body mass that they
VB> can't move in a more dynamic fashion.
Yes, there's probably something to this. At that level of
miniaturization, engineering considerations are much different.
Sophisticated feebacks and coordinations are not necessary to
protect weight-stressed legs.
VB>The possession of six legs allows the insect to always have
VB> four on the ground (or wherever) at any one time while
VB> moving.
I thought insects moved by means of "alternate tripods", but
I could well be wrong.
VB> The mechanism of hexapedal insects' motion is so simple that
VB> it may even be distributed at the base of the legs, and not
VB> in the brain at all. The brain might just send a "start
VB> walking" instruction, and the legs just start going. A sort
VB> of ripple-trigger arrangement of neurons assures the
VB> coordination; one leg actually signals the next. Same
VB> mechanism - in spades - helps the noble caterpillar and the
VB> honorable millipede to do what they do so well; thus the old
VB> dilemma posed by the cricket was a moot point.
Yes, though some of this processing will occur in the neural
ganglia in the *thorax*, but not in *head*.
VB> Robot designers like the hexapedal arrangement because it is
VB> more adaptable than wheels, but the walking motion can be
VB> frozen at any instant, and the carriage will still be fully
VB> supported by four legs.
And because it's safer (less likely to tumble) than
quadrapedalism, given our still limited ability to write a
quadrapedal program.
VB> Insect hexapods can't do this. Some can jump, but none can
VB> run in the sense that we are familiar with. They can, at
VB> best, just walk very, very fast.
Yes, I think many insects have only one forward speed.
VB> Horses' gaits come in a variety, but even they sometimes
VB> experience "interference". I use quotes, because that's a
VB> professional farrier's term; one or both rear hooves
VB> striking a front one. This is why they make orthopedic
VB> (well, correctional) horseshoes.
Yes, this would be a very serious problem for a hexapedal
horse. Some arthropods (eg millipedes) deal with this by very
short strides-- but this causes severe speed constrictions.
Some insects partially solve this by different-sized legs, eg
small middle legs which can be passed over by the rear legs, and
which can pass under the front legs. For a hexapedal horse,
where the legs are necessarily under the body, this would not be
an option.
VB> The walking gait (I think) is the only one in which the forelegs are not
VB> synchronized with the rear. I suspect that a hexapedal horse would
VB> move no better or faster than a quadrupedal one, because the more
VB> numerous legs would interfere more often.
The hexapedal horse would be slower.
--Volker
* SLMR 2.1a *
-+- OLMS 2.5p UNREG
--- FMail/386 1.0g
* Origin: Business Connection : Baltimore MD : 410-995-1809 : (1:261/1455)