Slimelite BBS

"Gods"

Back to APRIL

From Martyn Harrison · 1996-04-08 15:51 · #76438 in APRIL

TR> KD> However, my view on the point of life is that whether there is one or
TR> KD> isn't one is irrelevant, that we should live how we wish to regardless.
TR> "...we should live how we wish to regardless."

Seems a straightforward statement.

TR> Have I understood you correctly? Do you mean that you consider yourself
TR> free of all moral constraints?

That wasn't what he said.

TR> Do you think you could expand a little on that?

What reason do you have for thinking a moral code is something we all
need to have?

1 - If god(s) define a moral code, reward those who follow it and punish
those who don't then it makes sense to follow the code.

However, the moral codes which reportedly come from the various gods
around the world do not universally apply, and do not cater for all
cases in the modern world. Also, if god was so clever, he'd know that
various people will "read-up" on the moral codes and exploit the
loopholes.

If you don't believe in god then this is of no importance anyway.

2 - If god is to be dispensed with, the purpose of a moral code is to
determine the difference between good and bad behaviour. The only reason
to be good under those terms is (a) because you want to be seen as good,
or (b) because being good gives you advantages over being bad.

In which case, if things change such that a bad act will be of more
advantage to you it can be dispensed with. Like the person who finds a
tenner lying on the floor and pockets it. Optionally, the desire to be
seen as good is an emotional need, in which case the person can become
positively dangerous when the social approval is withdrawn. Most nutters
with guns believe they are acting morally.

Also, if there is no afterlife, what is the difference between good and
evil? Comes to nothing in the end either way.

3 - Moral codes might be imposed by clever people who see certain
behaviour as advantageous to society, rather than the individual. Many
laws and the like are designed this way. This has the obvious flaw in
it, which is how to persuade individuals that what is useful for society
as a whole should be followed rather than what is useful for the
individual and detrimental to society. This can be overcome by
brainwashing or a physical system of enforcement.

The Selfish Giant is a story all about a rich, but selfish, giant. He
finds contentment and happiness only when he distributes his wealth
among the poor, see also Scrooge and so forth. Rich people don't get or
stay rich by following this role model, but they are more than happy
that you, their competitor, does. Who is getting the better deal?

So, what is the basis for the moral code you follow? ;)

---
 * TLX v4.10 * Little boats should keep near the shore.

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin: Ooh! BBS, London [MULTILINES]  0181-395-3108  (2:254/233.0)